I can only recommend based on my experience. I bought a Roland Studio capture quite a few years ago.
 
It had very good reviews and at the time cakewalk was owned by Roland so it seemed like a good choice.
 
It has been excellent, no problems whatsoever it a;lso works without issue with everything else I have tried it with. Ableton live, pro tools. There are a number of interfaces with differing capabilities in this range.

Roland Quadcapture works fine, too - if the Studio capture would be a little bit oversized for you. If you use the cheap cables, pull and plug them sometimes to avoid hiss. Plug-/contact-Oxidation is evil sometimes ;-)
 

I can concur, my friend has an antelope interface and it is superb, albeit pricey.

RME have great stuff. I have a Fireface 800 since about a decade now. RME still keep updating the drivers for it. Great company.

Indeed - The Focusrite devices are great. Personally I do not like USB devices very much, because a lot of the cheaper ones have a high latency (and crackling and popping when you try to go lower), but the Focusrite ones are very decent. Make sure you have the latest generation tough, because the older(1.1) versions have some USB problems.
 
Personally I like firewire devices better. I still use an old MOTU Traveler (yes - first gen) with a TI interface under Windows 8.1, and it has a real low latency while it's rock steady. The MOTU interfaces are not the cheapest (although cheaper than RME), but have a real high quality. That said - This are, of course, my personal experiences.

That Cakewalk interface was great though wasn't it?  I had the same unit, bought as a package with Sonar Studio 6 and it lasted happily until a year or so ago.  Even then, it was still possible to get working under W10 and a few driver waltzes.
 
It will depend on what you need in terms of channels etc, but in my case I went for the RME BabyFace Pro.  Excellent unit - costly but it does what it's supposed to do.  Never crashes with the DAW (which oddly the Cakewalk unit used to do not infrequently), and it works just as flawlessly with Studio One as you'd expect.

I've used many USB audio interfaces over the years, and the one I'm sticking with now is the Focusrite Scarlett 18i8 second generation. Great sound quality, low latency, MIDI IN/OUT and great free effects bundle offers.
 
Previously I had the Presonus 1820VSL. Great sound quality, but its USB implementation was horrible. Constantly conflicting with other USB devices. But it did come with a version of Studio One, which I installed and discovered totally paled in comparison to Sonar. 
 
I would absolutely not worry about having to match an interface to work a particular DAW.  All interfaces should work with any DAW you use, since a DAW connects with the interface's drivers (usually ASIO). Nothing proprietary at all there. 

I'm using a UA-25EX on Win 10 with no issues.  What type of problems are you having?
 
Actually, I did have one issue...the Hi Def Audio on my graphics card will interfere with the UA-25EX (SONAR will say it doesn't exist).  The easy fix for this is to disable the Hi Def Audio on the graphics card.

Hi. If budget allows, I say go for RME. They make excellent products, and support old devices. Perhaps 2nd hand?
On the budget side (as Chuck mentioned), there is the Focusrite 2i4.
All the best.

I have a MOTU 828es (and had a MOTU AVB Ultralite before that).  If you don't have an X99 chipset, it works great and the feature set is incredible.

i use an RME Babyface Pro....
 
really like it.
 
it has a midi breakout cable, quite stout....
all depends on how many preamps you need.
 

I've used many interfaces over the years, most of them quite good. But I've recently moved to RME and I'll never look back. Best drivers in the business, IMHO, and great sounding hardware. If you can't afford their entry-level stuff, you can find used original Babyface units for pretty good prices. They work great, are durable, and RME strongly supports their older hardware. 

nickgorrell
Hi, My old cakewalk UA-25EX has died due to windows 10 and drivers

My UA-25EX works fine with Win 10, drivers automatically downloaded when I plugged the interface in.
 
I have over the years accumulated an Edirol UA-25EX, UA-101, Roland OctaCapture, QuadCapture, DuoCapture EXII, PreSonus, Tascam US1641, 1800, 16x08, 20x20, 2x2 and 1x2.
 
Edirols are great but there are better pres around in newer gear. The 101 still serves as an interface for all my rack gear.
 
I much prefer the new Tascams. Super low noise pres, no issues when connecting to other gear and low digital ground loop noise. I have always found Tascam quoted specs to be very conservative.
 
Earlier drivers had latency issues but all that is fixed now. In general I have the impression Tascam releases the product before the drivers are ready, which damages their reputation unnecessarily.
 
The Rolands are all microphonic when you tap them. The QuadCapture has a low hum on the instrument input which becomes audible when the track is compressed. The auto level setting concept doesn't work for me and the OctaCapture has especially high digital ground loop issues and has, perhaps for that reason, only 50dB gain max, but I use them for drums anyway (two can be used together). On the other hand, they all have drivers that work with XP, so I keep them for my mobile rig which is still XP.
 
The Presonus drivers have issues with some of my audio programs and it shows a silly icon whether I am using it or not. After a second version was released with other issues (and no development done anymore), my Presonus now resides in my dud gear box. My first and last Presonus.