Basic audio editing confusion in X2

Author
Erik_O
Max Output Level: -88 dBFS
  • Total Posts : 114
  • Joined: 2004/07/28 14:21:12
  • Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
  • Status: offline
2012/09/23 10:49:06 (permalink)

Basic audio editing confusion in X2

There are several things about basic manual audio editing in X2 (some of it applies to X1 as well) that I just don't understand the reasoning behind. I mentioned in an ealier thread, that when you turn off snapping, the Smart Grid will still be visible but not in a higher resolution that 1/4 note. When I edit, I will almost always need a grid at least a 1/16 note resolution and I just don't see the use of Smart Grid with snapping turned on. Fastbikerboy suggested to set the snap resolution high, but if you set it to lets say 1 tic, it's almost like there's no snapping, but as soon as zoom in or out, the resolution will change (that's the understandable nature of Smart Grid) and you'll have to change the snap setting to 1 tic again before the next editing.
 
I seems to me, that Smart Grid is created mainly to work along with the snapping turned on instead of turned off. Can someone please explain the reasoning behind that?
 
Another thing that bothers me is the way X2 behave, when you want to move a selection of a clip:
When you left-click and drag to either side, it will look like this:
 

 
The transparent, darker tone of the original clip color is very calm and comfortable to look at. Now, when you grab the selection and move it, it will become a new, active clip with a white background and you will still see a "ghost" version of the original selection in the background. I couldn't make a printscreen of the actual move, but if you try, you'll see what I mean (you probably already know what it looks like anyway )
 
Both the change of background color and the "ghost" selection is rather annoying and it makes it rather difficult to see what you are doing (remember, I'm talking about editing (pocketing) which means that you only want to move the clip slightly to either side)and again - I don't understand the reasoning.
 
After dragging and slipping the mouse, it looks like this:
 

 
Firstly, I don't understand why the background color of the clips is white, because I know I set "selected clip" to purple (I imported the color settings from X1 and it does say purple in the Preferences). Secondly, I don't understand why the moved clip and the clip it overlaps (to the left) are white - meaning they are selected clips - when I've set the "Selection after single split" to "None".
 
The ideal scenario when moving clips for minor adjustments (pocketing) to me would be to:
1. Have a fully functionable Smart Grid when snapping is off
2. Keep the transparent, darker tone of a selection when moving it
3. Let the moved clip and potential overlapped clips stay unselected
 
I'm not in any way an audio master and there may be something I've overlooked or misunderstood about X2's behavior. So if you've got a solution/suggestion to any of above, I'd be very thankful.
 
Best regards from...
post edited by Erik_O - 2012/09/27 15:39:55

Erik Oberg

Sonar is good. Sonar works!
 
#1

12 Replies Related Threads

    Erik_O
    Max Output Level: -88 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 114
    • Joined: 2004/07/28 14:21:12
    • Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/27 15:41:29 (permalink)
    Am I completely on my own on this one?

    Erik Oberg

    Sonar is good. Sonar works!
     
    #2
    mudgel
    Max Output Level: 0 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 12010
    • Joined: 2004/08/13 00:56:05
    • Location: Linton Victoria (Near Ballarat)
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/27 16:03:45 (permalink)
    spend the time to check out this video

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xw5z9BKWD-I

    I think it will explain a few things

    Mike V. (MUDGEL)

    STUDIO: Win 10 Pro x64, SPlat & CbB x64,
    PC: ASUS Z370-A, INTEL i7 8700k, 32GIG DDR4 2400, OC 4.7Ghz.
    Storage: 7 TB SATA III, 750GiG SSD & Samsung 500 Gig 960 EVO NVMe M.2.
    Monitors: Adam A7X, JBL 10” Sub.
    Audio I/O & DSP Server: DIGIGRID IOS & IOX.
    Screen: Raven MTi + 43" HD 4K TV Monitor.
    Keyboard Controller: Native Instruments Komplete Kontrol S88.
    #3
    FastBikerBoy
    Forum Host
    • Total Posts : 11326
    • Joined: 2008/01/25 16:15:36
    • Location: Watton, Norfolk, UK
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/27 16:40:41 (permalink)
    As I understand it the smart grid is reference to the variable snap resolution. If snap is off the smart grid is off by definition.

    As far as I can see you've selected part of a clip which will become a separate clip. If you want to move the whole clip click in the clip header which will move that rather than the selected part.

    I'm not sure I'm following the colour bit but it's dark initially to show it's a partial clip selection then as you start the move it becomes a single clip which is highlighted white/grey to show the whole clip (that it now is) is selected.

    HTH
    #4
    Erik_O
    Max Output Level: -88 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 114
    • Joined: 2004/07/28 14:21:12
    • Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 14:40:26 (permalink)
    FastBikerBoy


    As I understand it the smart grid is reference to the variable snap resolution. If snap is off the smart grid is off by definition.

    Hi Fastbiker,
     
    Now, that's exactly what I'm confused about. If you turn off snapping and zoom in and out, the Smart Grid will still reflect the zoom level, but it has got only two resolutions: whole notes or 1/4 notes.
    Obviously, I really hope that this is just a bug and that Smart Grid is supposed to behave the same way, whether snapping is on or off. I sent a report to Cakewalk yesterday, but haven't heard from them yet.
     
    FastBikerBoy

    As far as I can see you've selected part of a clip which will become a separate clip. If you want to move the whole clip click in the clip header which will move that rather than the selected part.

    I'm not sure I'm following the colour bit but it's dark initially to show it's a partial clip selection then as you start the move it becomes a single clip which is highlighted white/grey to show the whole clip (that it now is) is selected.
    I'm sorry if I made this part sound more complicated than it actually is. My question on moving clips is not really about what Sonar does, it's about the way it does it and actually Sonar doesn't even differ in this area from the other DAWs I've tried.
    What I would like is the option to have the selection in the first picture to look the same (darkened) when I drag it (when it becomes a new clip) and to still look the same after I drop it in the new spot.
    I honestly don't see what purpose the change of background color and having the original clip in the background serve. I imagine it would be much more friendly for the eye without that.
     
    I'm a bit surprised that no-one seems to support me on the smart grid part. It makes me uncertain of the way I use Sonar, because I'm definitely not an expert in any way. Do you guys all use Audio Snap for audio editing or do you just hit the beat right on?
     

    Erik Oberg

    Sonar is good. Sonar works!
     
    #5
    synkrotron
    Max Output Level: -22.5 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 5263
    • Joined: 2006/04/28 16:21:21
    • Location: Warrington, UK
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 14:42:56 (permalink)
    I'm a midician not a musician so I have no problem hitting the beat :-)

    http://www.synkrotron.co.uk/
    Intel Core™i7-3820QM Quad Core Mobile Processor 2.70GHz 8MB cache | Intel HM77 Express Chipset | 16GB SAMSUNG 1600MHz SODIMM DDR3 RAM | NVIDIA GeForce GTX 675M - 2.0GB DDR5 Video RAM | 500GB Samsung 850 Pro SSD | 1TB Samsung 850 Pro SSD | Windows 10 Pro | Roland OCTA-CAPTURE | SONAR Platinum ∞ FFS| Too many VSTi's to list here | KRK KNS-8400 Headphones | Roland JP-8000 | Oberheim OB12 | Novation Nova | Gibson SG Special | PRS Studio
    #6
    FastBikerBoy
    Forum Host
    • Total Posts : 11326
    • Joined: 2008/01/25 16:15:36
    • Location: Watton, Norfolk, UK
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 14:59:20 (permalink)
    Erik_O


    FastBikerBoy


    As I understand it the smart grid is reference to the variable snap resolution. If snap is off the smart grid is off by definition.

    Hi Fastbiker,
     
    Now, that's exactly what I'm confused about. If you turn off snapping and zoom in and out, the Smart Grid will still reflect the zoom level, but it has got only two resolutions: whole notes or 1/4 notes.
    Obviously, I really hope that this is just a bug and that Smart Grid is supposed to behave the same way, whether snapping is on or off. I sent a report to Cakewalk yesterday, but haven't heard from them yet. 
      
     
    I'm a bit surprised that no-one seems to support me on the smart grid part. It makes me uncertain of the way I use Sonar, because I'm definitely not an expert in any way. Do you guys all use Audio Snap for audio editing or do you just hit the beat right on?
     
    I don't see that behaviour with the Smart Grid. If it is off but snap is on then it behaves like the old snap, i.e. one set resolution. If the smart grid is the setting but the snap is off it doesn't respond at all to zoom level.
     
    Not sure why you are seeing different but I don't think it's expected behaviour.

    #7
    Erik_O
    Max Output Level: -88 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 114
    • Joined: 2004/07/28 14:21:12
    • Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 15:00:33 (permalink)
    synkrotron


    I'm a midician not a musician so I have no problem hitting the beat :-)


    Around 30 percent of the time I'm a midician as well and when I am, I really appreciate to have all the grids in the world - with or without snapping enabled.
    So, you actually hit the nail right on the head

    Erik Oberg

    Sonar is good. Sonar works!
     
    #8
    Erik_O
    Max Output Level: -88 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 114
    • Joined: 2004/07/28 14:21:12
    • Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 15:21:06 (permalink)
    FastBikerBoy

     
    I don't see that behaviour with the Smart Grid. If it is off but snap is on then it behaves like the old snap, i.e. one set resolution. If the smart grid is the setting but the snap is off it doesn't respond at all to zoom level. 
     
    Well, that is strange. This is a print screen of the project with snapping turned off and Smart Grid checked:
     

     
    And this is what it looks like after Ctrl+1 click on the right arrow:
     


     

    Erik Oberg

    Sonar is good. Sonar works!
     
    #9
    FastBikerBoy
    Forum Host
    • Total Posts : 11326
    • Joined: 2008/01/25 16:15:36
    • Location: Watton, Norfolk, UK
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 15:39:15 (permalink)
    I see the same thing in the drop down, but AFAIK it's just an inactive setting. It doesn't do anything until snap is turned on. I thought you meant that the zoom level was responding while switched off in the same way it does while it's on.

    That I don't see.
    #10
    Erik_O
    Max Output Level: -88 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 114
    • Joined: 2004/07/28 14:21:12
    • Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 16:22:22 (permalink)
    FastBikerBoy


    I see the same thing in the drop down, but AFAIK it's just an inactive setting. It doesn't do anything until snap is turned on. I thought you meant that the zoom level was responding while switched off in the same way it does while it's on.

    That I don't see.
    I think we're misunderstanding each other here, Fastbiker I included the drop down menu just to make my settings visible. The focus should be on the grid line resolution.
     FastBikerBoy


     I thought you meant that the zoom level was responding while switched off in the same way it does while it's on.
     
    I'm afraid I don't understand this sentence (forgive me ). The pictures were supposed to illustrate that the Smart Grid does respond to zooming, although snapping is off.
    My wish is, that Smart Grid will respond to zooming with snapping turned off, but with any resolution. Not just the two shown in the pics, as it is now.

    Erik Oberg

    Sonar is good. Sonar works!
     
    #11
    FastBikerBoy
    Forum Host
    • Total Posts : 11326
    • Joined: 2008/01/25 16:15:36
    • Location: Watton, Norfolk, UK
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 16:39:56 (permalink)
    Ah gotcha, I rarely have gridlines visible so I haven't noticed. I think that's probably the same as the PRV then which IIRC when following snap either displays the current snap or if it's off then displays either quarter beat lines or measure lines depending on zoom level.

    I think what you are seeing is by design but I'm guessing TBH.
    #12
    Erik_O
    Max Output Level: -88 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 114
    • Joined: 2004/07/28 14:21:12
    • Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
    • Status: offline
    Re:Basic audio editing confusion in X2 2012/09/28 17:49:41 (permalink)
    FastBikerBoy


    Ah gotcha, I rarely have gridlines visible so I haven't noticed. I think that's probably the same as the PRV then which IIRC when following snap either displays the current snap or if it's off then displays either quarter beat lines or measure lines depending on zoom level.

    I think what you are seeing is by design but I'm guessing TBH.

    I gave up finding any consistency in the relationship between the grid in PRV and the snap settings in TR, but in the PRV you have at least the option to turn off  "Follow Snap Settings" and choose a resolution. PRV will then display that grid resolution whether snapping is on or off and regardless the zoom level.
     
    Bakers please, could we have a Smart Grid that acts as if snapping is on even if it is off?

    Erik Oberg

    Sonar is good. Sonar works!
     
    #13
    Jump to:
    © 2025 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1