Re: Best Practices for MIDI tracks?
2013/08/03 11:12:18
(permalink)
In the beginning the word "Velocity" was used instead of volume because the dudes were mostly trying to emulate piano/synth keyboard actions. Velocity: the speed at which fingers impact keys.
But it is volume. Albeit with less precision that audio volume.
How the midi message is used by a receiving device (soft/hard) is all about programming. All midi devices send the same structure of midi message: header with CC number, followed by number from 0 to 127. (yea, I know this is simplified.)
What is done with the message depends upon the programming of the receiving device: volume, pan, triggering layers, controlling stage lights,...
Of course this is really no different than how any device reacts to and modifies audio: EQ, Pan, compressor...
Cuz it's all just zeros and ones.
==================
I have separate midi track for each "percussion/rhythm" related sound. This is because I use lots of cal scripts to generate and modify the clips: insert on the 1 of every 8, delete the 4 of 6, change note, velocity,... And many of the midi clips are created from AS. (example July 4 fireworks, snapped to 1/16, 1/8, 1/4, and then copied as midi to multiple tracks to trigger other noises.)
I layer sounds a lot: a quick DP pizzicato violin with a SD tom, slightly offset, and a Dropzone captured noise,... hence the need of 3 midi tracks for ease of use.
With single midi tracks I can quickly change the note-key in the track properties, without having to open a PRV.
Sometimes I do send the midi signal to a midi pipe and into each instrument, and then use delay if needed. But I find it easier to have a separate midi track for each sound.
I do not think of SD as a single instrument.
I am not a trap-set kind of guy. In general I hate ride cymbals, and loud snare drums.
I do use the input controls of the midi track (velocity) and the audio track (trim), and the midi track volume to adjust the level (volume) of the sound.
Example: at the point when track and clip envelopes are happy and overall balance is good, but I want a little more of one sound, increasing the trim of the tracks usually will not affect the tone of the sound, and I do not have to adjust envelopes, and bus volumes,...
This means I do not always leave the midi track at unity.
I have tried all kinds of track arrangements. Sure would be nice if I could put folders in folders.
Lately I have been having a separate folder containing the midi track(s) and instrument(s). This is because I am constantly adjusting the midi notes' values, and the instruments settings. Lots less scrolling for me.