X1B Controller Reset Bug ? (now with Video)

From every test I did in the last half hour, it seems X1B has another bug regarding controllers.

I have 2 guitar tracks (using Kontakt4) that have sustain pedals in them (controller 64).

When I hit stop it's as if the sustain pedal is still down and the notes keep going (unless I hit stop just at the right point where there's a sustain pedal off data).  Like a hung note.

So I realized I didn't have "Reset All Controllers On Stop" set in X1B.   So I set it.

It does not work (for me) with sustain pedal (CC 64).

So, just to be sure it wasn't a patch problem or a Kontakt problem,  I opened the same file in 8.5.3 (which has "Reset Controllers On Stop" Checked...  and it works properly!   It also works properly without that setting!

So then I tried creating a fresh project in both X1B and 8.5.3 using the same guitar multipatch and doing the same experiment.  Same results:

X1B does NOT reset controller 64 on Stop.
8.5.3 DOES reset controller 64 properly.

I haven't tried other controllers yet but CC64 is a no go (for me).

I would ask that some of you try this and confirm this please?

Thanks.

I can't reproduce with hardware synths, single-channel soft-synths like TruePianos or the multi-channel JABB. Piano sustains are stopped normally in all cases.

The crosstalk bug relates to MIDI input, so I don't that would be relevant, either. Something else going on in your config, or maybe with Kontakt or those patches, specifically.

 

Ok here's 2 videos.

First is in X1 ... I hit play, then stop, then play (you'll see the  timeline stop/go).

Second is the same project brought into 8.5.3 doing the same thing - but it works properly.   The difference in sound is just because 8.5.3 doesn't have the Pro Channel (which should make no difference for this).

1st one:

http://ba-midi.com/Tests/X1_CC64.mov

2nd one:

http://ba-midi.com/Tests/S853_CC64.mov

This doesn't seem to be a kontakt/patch problem to me!

Notice I'm purposely stopping when there is CC64 data (on) to prove the point as to how X1 and 8.5.3 handle this differently.