Hey bapu,
Thanks for listening. I re-listened with your crits in mind and I think you may be onto something with the vocals. I originally thought the pumping had been occurring within the electric rhythm guitar track. I'm going to go back into the mix and remove some compression on the lead vocal track and see if that helps.
Everything else that you mentioned, (muddy bass, not much in the way of changes, kick drum) was actually intended as you described, based on the input from everyone involved on the project. I checked out some of the stuff on your website (some very cool songs, btw) and I think we simply have some different tastes/preferences on tone.
Thanks again for the vocal tip. I'm gonna go hit up that mix right now and see what I can come up with.
Thanks,
Reid