Scottytunes
Max Output Level: -18.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 5695
- Joined: 2009/01/09 23:48:53
- Location: Vermont
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/05 22:31:37
(permalink)
ABeautifulVirus dude- you're a friggin' awesome metal guitar player w/ an equally awesome voice. love the stereo spread in this mix. the deep E string bend-flats remind me of the last Alice In Chains album. vocals have this Ozzy meets Dokken vibe but with your own unique vocal stamp as well. harmonies are sweet and remind me a bit of Ratt. i LOVED this. great tune. A+ Absolutely DITTO! Great job, Bob!
|
BIABDude
Max Output Level: -77 dBFS
- Total Posts : 676
- Joined: 2010/01/24 20:32:32
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/09 11:28:04
(permalink)
+++1 song -- -- perfect voice for this style
|
Janet
Max Output Level: 0 dBFS
- Total Posts : 8094
- Joined: 2010/01/02 19:04:11
- Location: Missouri
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/09 22:02:03
(permalink)
It sounds like everything still works just fine and you haven't forgotten anything. :) Nice!!!
|
Bob Oister
Max Output Level: -47.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2766
- Joined: 2008/01/10 00:34:27
- Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/15 05:18:36
(permalink)
NOTE: Sorry for the late replies! bapu: Hey, Ed, Thanks so much, buddy, I really appreciate you checking it out and also your comments! My friend, in my opinion, you definitely have an excellent set of very trustworthy ears! Your comment about the slight difference in my guitar sound on this absolutely amazed me. Because after getting the new computer setup and optimizing it, and then installing all of the software and plugins and reauthorizing and updating, when I finally got started doing some recording I noticed a slightly different overall sound, but mainly noticeable in the rhythm guitars. At first I just attributed it to not recording anything for over five months, and not having my "studio ears" back yet. As I recorded some more bits and pieces of a couple more test tracks, and then listened to a few of the previous songs from my CD, I kept noticing a very slight difference, as you mentioned, not necessarily bad, but just a bit darker (yet thinner) than usual. So I started doing some back to back test tracks using the exact same guitar, same amps, same effects settings, all going through the same busses/effects and interface and monitors as always, and was still noticing a slight difference from the general sound of the earlier projects on the old PC. It was driving me nuts, but I was determined to figure it out, so next I decided to check my Sonar audio/buffers settings and immediately noticed that apparently during one of the updates of the drivers for my interface, the Line 6 device control panel switched the record bit depth from 24 bit down to 16 bit. I have always recorded in Sonar using 24 bit and then triangular dithered down to 16 bit when exporting the final mixes for CD. Anyway, LOL, to make a long story even longer, I changed the record bitrate back to 24 and did another test, and BANG!, all back to normal! So I apparently have to do some very focused EQ surgery on the rhythm guitar and bass tracks on this song and the other three that I had already started before I detected and fixed the problem. Anyway, thanks again for lending me your good ears, and your kind comments, I always look forward to and appreciate your input and observations. Have a good one, Ed! Bob ---------------------------------------------------------------------- The Band 19: Hey, Robby, How's it going, buddy? Doing great, I hope! Thanks for checking it out, and for your kind words. Yes, sir, you've got that right, after five months, I was really dying to get back up and running and start recording again. I just hope that I can get my recording and mixing "chops" back in shape fairly quickly. I remember that you mentioned having your DAW crash and burn for a few weeks over the summer, so I'm sure you know what it's like to really miss being able to do this stuff! Thanks again, Robby, and by the way, your recent Bad Company collab with Mark was fantastic, really great stuff. Have a good one! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------- timidi: Hey Tim, How's it going? Hope you're doing great! Thank you very much for checking it out and also for your kind words and input! Yep, I think I might have jumped in early on the final chorus for the "Can it" and then hesitated and paused maybe one beat too long before the "Be the same" to try to make up for it. I think that's what it has to be, because when I mute the vocal buses the timing seems perfect with just the music playing. Hopefully a "scissors and nudge" in one direction or another will tighten it back up. I've heard it so many times that it's hard for me to be sure that's what the little timing glitch actually is. Thanks for listening and pointing that out, hopefully I'll be able to get back to touching this one up over the weekend. Have a great weekend, Tim! Bob ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- PGShadow: Hey, Kev, Thanks a bunch, brother! I was away for a while and slammed at work, so I'm hoping to get back to putting the finishing touches on this one over the weekend. I should probably have the second mix up by Tuesday. I really appreciate you taking time to give this a listen and your kind words, your input really means a lot to me. Have a great weekend, Kev! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------- mcourter: Hey, Mark, It's really great to see you back around the forum! How are, brother? Hope you're doing great! Thanks so much for giving this a listen and for your very encouraging comments, that really means a lot to me! By new DAW, I mean a new PC. For recording software I'm still using good old Sonar PE 8.53, although, I must say the latest video for X2 has me chomping at the bit to check it out when the demo is released for a possible upgrade! Hey, by the way, really nice job on your cool vintage sounding blues post, great keyboards and guitars, good stuff! Thanks again, Mark, you've been a long time good friend of mine here on the forum and on the old original Line 6 forum. I really appreciate your friendship and support! Have a good one, buddy! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Guitarpima: Hey Robert, It's really great to hear from you, man! Thank you very much for checking this one out for me, and for your great comments. Yeah, LOL, maybe a warning label and optional cervical collar like in the old "Wayne's World" movies would do the trick! Thanks again, Robert, your input and friendship means a great deal to me. Keep on Rockin', brother! Bob ---------------------------------------------------------------------
|
eric paul
Max Output Level: -86 dBFS
- Total Posts : 241
- Joined: 2011/12/24 14:05:17
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/15 09:12:51
(permalink)
hi bob awesome production well done eric
|
Bob Oister
Max Output Level: -47.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2766
- Joined: 2008/01/10 00:34:27
- Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/15 19:05:00
(permalink)
drumstixkev: Hey, Kev, Thanks very much, buddy, I really appreciate you lending your ears to this, and your kind words of encouragement! Yes, sir, it's always a major pain reloading and reauthorizing, reupdating and transferring software and project backups to a new system, but it's always worth it in the end when you finally get the bugs worked out. Other than the strange little bitrate glitch that I mentioned above to Bapu, which had me baffled for a while, I think I'm back to smooth sailing again. Thanks again, Kev, and that was a pretty cool repost of your first ever song forum post from way back in 2008. That was a nice trip down memory lane. Have a good weekend! Bob ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- g_randybrown: Hey, Randy, How are, you? Doing great, I hope! Thank you very much, sir, I truly appreciate you taking time to check it out for me, and your and especially your encouraging comments! Your input and opinion means a great deal to me. By the way, I just want to mention that your latest song on your Soundclick page, "Clouds to Water" is absolutely fantastic! What an amazing piece of high quality inspirational music, very pro sounding stuff, excellent work. Much thanks again, Randy, and have a great weekend! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Wookie: Hi, John, Haw are you, my friend? Enjoying your weekend, I hope! Thanks so much for giving this a listen for me, and for your very kind words, I always look forward to and greatly appreciate your input and observations, and value your friendship highly! Best wishes! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- FreddyJ: Hi, Freddy, How's it going, buddy? Hope all is well in your neck of the woods! Thank you for checking this one out for me, and for your very kind words of support! Yes, sir, after finishing up my CD back in April, I decided to take a little break and revamp my recording setup. It really feels great to get back to recording again with a fresh perspective, and I'm hoping to be able to get my chops back into shape soon. Much thanks, Freddy, and have a great weekend, buddy! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- guitartrek: Hey, Geno, How are you, brother? It's really great to hear from you! Thank you for popping in for a listen on this one, and also for your encouraging words and good input! As I mentioned to Tim up above, I think the slight timing glitch at the last chorus might be in the vocal tracks, because with all the vocals muted, it doesn't seem to be there. I'm going to try to see if a nudge or two might be able to fix it up. It's funny, when I'm mixing, it's easy to listen to this stuff so many times that you can actually get "immune" to some of the little inconsistencies, and sometimes that makes them hard to put you finger on. To me, that's part of why this forum is such a great place, because you have so many very talented, helpful sets of ears to help pinpoint the little flies in the ointment. Thanks again, Geno, I always look forward to and greatly appreciate your input and observations. Especially because of your amazing musical skills and the pro quality of all your productions. Have a great weekend! Bob ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
Bob Oister
Max Output Level: -47.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2766
- Joined: 2008/01/10 00:34:27
- Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/16 17:36:47
(permalink)
Chappel: Hey, how are you, buddy? Going great, I hope! Thanks so much for stopping by to check this one out for me, and for your kind words and very good input! Yep, I think I hear what you mean during the first verse on the words "arms" and "charms". They sound a bit odd to me as they trail off, I don't actually think they're dropping flat (although I also do that sometimes ), to me, they're just weird sounding inflection-wise. Luckily, I always sing the vocals straight through three times using track layers, in case I screw something up, so I can pinpoint a bad note or stumble and then splice in a syllable or word from another take to fix it up. Thanks for pointing it out, that's a big part of what makes this place so great. Getting helpful input and observations from what other people are hearing on their end, that might be easily missed from being so close to a song while working on it. Thanks again, your input and observations are always very helpful and greatly appreciated. Have a good one! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- geeare1: Hey, Gary, What's up, buddy? Hope you're having a great weekend! Thank you kindly for giving this a listen and for your very encouraging comments! I really appreciate it coming from a musician of your caliber, because your songs and productions are always totally pro quality. Much thanks for all your input, support and friendship, Have a godd one, Gary! Bob -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- jamesyoyo: Hey, James, How are you, brother? Hope you're enjoying a great weekend! Thank you very much for giving this a listen for me, and for your very kind words! You've always been one of the most helpful contributors here on the forum, and I've learned a ton about mixing from your always specific and very good advice and input. Yes, sir, thanks for the kind offer, your drum tracks are always excellent, so I'll definitely keep you in mind for the right type of project in the future. Thanks again, James, I'm always very grateful for your input, observations, ideas and suggestions. Have a great night! Bob -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
Bob Oister
Max Output Level: -47.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2766
- Joined: 2008/01/10 00:34:27
- Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/19 04:53:34
(permalink)
Scottytunes: Hey, Scotty, How's it going, buddy? It's really great to see you back on the forum! Mucho thanks, Scott, for checking it out and for your encouraging words! I always look forward to and greatly appreciate your input, and value your advice, support and friendship very highly! Have a good one! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ BIABDude: Hey, Dude, Thanks so much, brother, I really appreciate you taking time to give this a listen and also your very kind comment! Greatly appreciated, my friend, and have a great day! Bob ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|
mgh
Max Output Level: 0 dBFS
- Total Posts : 8594
- Joined: 2007/05/10 05:15:56
- Location: betwixt and between
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/20 10:29:04
(permalink)
great song, riffs, playing as ever. You have a very distinctive ultra-saturated guitar tone. with James on the drums being the weakest link, they sound a lot brighter than the rest of the mix.
|
Bob Oister
Max Output Level: -47.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2766
- Joined: 2008/01/10 00:34:27
- Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/22 18:41:01
(permalink)
Janet: Hi, Janet, Thanks so much for checking this one out for me, and for your very kind words! Yes, it was a bit unsettling hitting the "restart' button after five months and setting up all the software, drivers and plugins again on the new PC, but I'm slowing getting back into the recording groove again. Thanks for lending me your ears, have a great weekend! Bob ==================================== eric paul: Hi, Eric, Thanks very much, buddy, I really appreciate you taking time to give this a listen for me, and your very encouraging input! I just want to mention that your recent remix post for your song "Let's Dance" was fantastic, great stuff, Eric! I'm very grateful for your input and observations, and I'm happy that you like the song. Have a good one! Bob ==================================== mgh: Hey, Mark, It's great to see you back around on the forum, hope you're doing great! Thanks for checking in on this one for me and for your kind comments and observations. I have a feeling the brightness you mentioned on the drums might be a bit of magnified contrast to the accidentally darker (or just different) than usual guitars caused by my accidentally recording everything in 16bit after the driver update error that I mentioned to Bapu above. I'm hoping to smooth things out a little with some EQ blending on tracks and buses to try to get things glued together a bit better on the remix. Thanks again for your always good observations and suggestions, I always look forward to, and appreciate your input and ideas. Have a great weekend, Mark! Bob =====================================
|
paulo
Max Output Level: -13 dBFS
- Total Posts : 6218
- Joined: 2007/01/30 05:06:57
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/23 09:41:00
(permalink)
Great production Bob - no surprises there I guess - you seem to have your musical style/sound pretty well nailed. I don't really feel in any position to give mix advice to you, but if you were to insist I'd say that that the drums just seemed to be a little on the bright side.
|
Makzimia
Max Output Level: -85 dBFS
- Total Posts : 258
- Joined: 2012/09/21 22:32:41
- Location: England
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/23 10:21:52
(permalink)
Hi Bob, nice to meet you, great song. I had to listen to everyones songs this morning with my DT100s on.. not the best way. I felt this one definitely needed my HR824s to do any justice to it :). If I may make one critique, some of the guitar balance is a little off still against the drums.. but, again, could be my headphones not giving me much of the bottom end. Cheers, Tony
Tony Carpenter Castille Productions Sonar Platinum//Cubase 10 Pro//Logic Pro X Mac Pro Dual Xeon 6 core 3.46ghz 32GB RAM UA Apollo Quad FireWire, UAD2 Quad, X-touch, NI 12 Ultimate Collectors, Montage 7
|
jayhill
Max Output Level: -79 dBFS
- Total Posts : 578
- Joined: 2005/03/22 21:45:53
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/26 14:00:47
(permalink)
Good "in my face" rock. Like the tone of the guitars. The beginning guitar intro - smoother left to right transition....maybe a tish of distant ambience added in the right ear...just rambling thoughts...lol. I enjoyed it.
|
THE NIGHT FOX
Max Output Level: -72 dBFS
- Total Posts : 922
- Joined: 2012/05/23 16:46:27
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/26 23:37:09
(permalink)
Hi Bob don't know how this song of your slip by me , maybe because I have too busy trying to catch up with you . Yea right , maybe someday when I'm old and gray sitting in a rest home wondering if my PC is going to blow a fuse at any moment ! LOL Hey this song rocks as all of your songs do , one thing I did noticed is at the beginning in the mix . I'm getting one sound in my right headphone , five seconds later I get all sound in both ears . Nice work as always , love your guitar playing keepem coming ! James
|
kennywtelejazz
Max Output Level: -3.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 7151
- Joined: 2005/10/22 06:27:02
- Location: The Planet Tele..X..
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/27 05:26:08
(permalink)
Hi Bob, I can sure feel you on what it takes to get back here... You have done an excellent job all across the board with this song . i enjoyed the vocals a lot , love the super phat heavy guitar rhythm playing , yeah man , you do have some real nice guitar tones going on . also really dug that kick drum...Kenny
|
Bob Oister
Max Output Level: -47.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2766
- Joined: 2008/01/10 00:34:27
- Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/28 04:27:19
(permalink)
NOTE: Mix #2 up now, thanks to everyone for your good input, observations and advice! After everyone's observations, for the remix, I added a touch of grit with a bitcrusher to the bass guitar, did a little bit of EQ surgery on the bass tracks, beefed up the low end on the drum bus a little bit and low-passed out some of the brightness that a few of you mentioned on the drums. Hopefully it's sounding better, and the overall volume levels are still pretty even. Please let me know if you think anything way out of whack! Thanks again, folks, for your input! Bob ============================================ paulo: Hey, Paulo, How are you, buddy? Doing well, I hope! Thank you very much for checking in on this one for me, and for your kind comments and good input! After both you and Mark mentioning the overly bright drums, for this second mix I beefed up the bottom end on the drum bus a little bit and slid down the low pass filter a few notches to try to take the edge off the high end a little and control the "contrast" with the dark rhythm guitars. Thanks very much for your observations and input, I greatly appreciate you giving it a listen. Best wishes! Bob ============================================== Makzimia: Hey, Tony, It's a pleasure to meet you, my new friend, and welcome to the forum! Thank you very much for taking time to give this song a listen and for your kind words and observations. As I mentioned to Paulo above, for this second mix I took your advice, along with Paulo's and Mark's, and pumped up the low end on the drum bus a bit and pulled out some of the highs to alleviate some of the brightness. I'm hoping it did the trick and that it will have a little more bottom end on your headphones and monitors. Thanks again for your input, Tony, getting good feedback on what others are hearing on their systems, in their own listening environment, is what makes this forum such a great place for helpful input on a mix. Much appreciated, have a great weekend! Bob ============================================= jayhill: Hey, Jay, Thanks so much for giving this song a listen for me, and for your very encouraging words and input! I really appreciate you checking it out and taking time to comment. I also just want to mention that your song, "Our Shining Star" on your Soundclick page is absolutely fantastic! It's a commercial quality pop song with great sounding guitars, a spectacular female vocalist and pro sounding production work. Really good stuff! Thanks again, Jay, and have a great weekend! Bob =============================================
|
SteveStrummerUK
Max Output Level: 0 dBFS
- Total Posts : 31112
- Joined: 2006/10/28 10:53:48
- Location: Worcester, England.
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/28 07:09:22
(permalink)
Wow! This is just wonderful Bob Love the guitar work as always, and I'm really enjoying the extra 'darkness'. Definitely a keeper my friend. BTW Bob, I've still got your CD in my car and it gets a regular play through
|
Makzimia
Max Output Level: -85 dBFS
- Total Posts : 258
- Joined: 2012/09/21 22:32:41
- Location: England
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/28 12:24:33
(permalink)
Hey Bob, MUCH better!!. Admittedly, the HR824s got used this time, but, I can hear the mix difference overall too, nice work mate!. Tony
Tony Carpenter Castille Productions Sonar Platinum//Cubase 10 Pro//Logic Pro X Mac Pro Dual Xeon 6 core 3.46ghz 32GB RAM UA Apollo Quad FireWire, UAD2 Quad, X-touch, NI 12 Ultimate Collectors, Montage 7
|
Bob Oister
Max Output Level: -47.5 dBFS
- Total Posts : 2766
- Joined: 2008/01/10 00:34:27
- Location: Scranton, Pennsylvania USA
- Status: offline
Re:"The Same" (Modern Rock) - First Recording in 5 Months!
2012/09/30 19:43:21
(permalink)
THE NIGHT FOX: Hi, James, Thanks so much for checking this song out for me and for your kind words! Yes, Sir, during the intro the left guitar comes in by itself, and then the right side a couple seconds later, so that was what was intended. You may have just had your headphones on backwards when you gave it a listen, so what you heard seemed reversed. Hey, by the way, you did a great job on your latest post "It Makes No Sense to ME", nice work on the vocals! Thanks again, James, I appreciate your input and comments, have a great night, buddy! Bob =================================================== kennywtelejazz: Hey, Kenny, How are you, brother? Having a great weekend, I hope! Thank you very much for giving this one a listen for me, and for your very encouraging comments! I really appreciate your input and observations, especially coming from a phenomenal player like yourself. Much thanks, Kenny, and have a rockin' weekend! Bob =================================================== SteveStrummerUK: Hey, Steve, How's my best pal from across the water doing? Hope you had a fantastic weekend! Sincere thanks for checking in on this one for me and for your kind comments and input! As I mentioned a few times before, your kick-butt guitar tone, playing style and the great music on your VeRy Metal and Strummy Soundclick pages was one of the main reasons that I joined the forum in the first place, and your continued input, advice, friendship and support truly means a great deal to me. Besides, us kindred spirit 80's metal guys have to stick together to keep the fire burning for the future, roight? Also, thanks so much for the comment about the CD, to me, that's the best feeling and greatest compliment ever, when someone tells me that they still play the CD on a regular basis after they've already had it a few months. That really makes all the time spent and hard work learning this stuff and constantly testing and experimenting with new techniques and ideas all worthwhile to me. Much appreciated, Steve, and thank you again, my friend! Bob =================================================== Makzimia: Hey, Tony, Thank you very much for coming back for a second listen to the remix for comparison after the changes! I'm very grateful for your input and observations that mix #2 was a move in the right direction. That type of very helpful information from a second listen is always highly valuable and greatly appreciated. Since getting into learning digital recording and mixing, I've always said that it reminds me of getting a standard vision test at the eye doctor's office. Every single click of the mouse on a slider, EQ, compressor, envelope or effect knob has to be looked at as either "better or worse" just like the lens changes in a vision test, in order to confirm that all the little details are working together in a project. Thanks again for coming back to check the remix and for your kind comments, Tony. Best wishes! Bob ====================================================
|