A user review of the A800 pro

Author
aj
Max Output Level: -69 dBFS
  • Total Posts : 1084
  • Joined: 2003/12/08 08:21:36
  • Status: offline
2012/10/17 14:42:39 (permalink)

A user review of the A800 pro

Apologies for the truly dreadful formatting of this message. For some reason I just CANNOT get paragraphs in there, even after re-editing the post. Well, recently my Novation Remote 61LE started behaving erratically, constantly sending random CCs and stuff over MIDI. It's probably just a bad cap which I can certainly fix but I always regretted buying it - the keyboard velocity response is just... weird... and you just can't get a smooth response no matter which curve you choose. It's cheap but nasty. So, time to buy a new 61 note controller keyboard. I already have a weighted 88 note master keyboard which is actually a Technics SX-P30 piano - which has no controls other than the keyboard - and a Korg X5D synth which has given many excellent years of service, but certainly doesn't have useful knobs and buttons, not to mention drawbars. Since this time I wasn't going to end up with another sucky keyboard, I looked carefully at the options and unfortunately they pretty much lead to only one choice, the A800. Not cheap, but certainly well built. So, having gotten it fairly integrated with the rest of the studio gear, some observations. THE GOOD The quality of the hardware is certainly excellent. The keyboard velocity response is smooth, the keys are nice, the buttons and knobs move smoothly and precisely. The 8 pads can send aftertouch individually and are velocity sensitive. Buttons light up when you press them. THE BAD The keyboard aftertouch requires fairly hefty pressure on the keys to activate it. It is, however, still playable and largely compensates for the spring-loaded modulation and pitch joystick - normally I disconnect the modulation axis spring and this is probably doable with some warranty-voiding disassembly, but with aftertouch, I can just assign modulation to aftertouch which greatly simplifies playing guitar lines with RealStrat, since you want a free hand for pitch bending anyway. (this is why separate mod and pitch wheels, in my opinion are inferior to a combined joystick.) There are a bunch of switches with tiny writing on the top and engraved (but utterly unreadable in any reasonable light) writing on the unit side that do necessary (power off/on) and strange (midi merge on/off - why on earth does that need a tiny dedicated switch just ready to be flicked the wrong way during a gig setup, I don't know). THE UGLY The software!. If the Martians ever invade and figure out the purpose of music, this is the kind of software they might create....Where do I start... Well, first, lets look at all those knobs and buttons. 11 switches, and, to a large extent,one knob, are permanently dedicated to functions that many of us simply don't want or need. A dedicated transpose button?. Octave transposition switches as well?. A dedicated ACT button that is totally useless if you don't use Sonar?. (and unfortunately I no longer do. It's a long story, I won't bore you...) So the actual complement of knobs and sliders is somewhat reduced. Sure, there are four general purpose buttons plus a full set of transport controls which can be programmed to do anything but which you probably want to control the transport anyway - not a bad thing, to be fair. And then nine sliders for drawbars, etc, eight drum pads which are reprogrammable as general purpose buttons, and a VLINK button which - thank goodness - is reprogrammable. At this point the first of the seriously Martian decisions shows up. There's a dedicated shift key but it never occurred to Roland to make this affect the buttons and controllers. A great opportunity to double the controllability - squandered!. This is seriously annoying and doubly so because the sole purpose of the shift key is to enable numeric values to be input using some of the other buttons. But - guess what - this doesn't work for the one place it really needs to - sending program change messages. No, you have to increment/decrement using the master control knob. Now, do you have any idea how SLOOOW that gets with some hardware (and software synths)..... Let me just walk through some of the other truly stupid software design decisions. You can only send MIDI data to the MIDI out port when you have an external power supply plugged in and you've switched USB off. Those of us who have external hardware synths AND a computer didn't figure in Roland's genius decision here. To be fair, you can work round this by setting up MIDI-OX on your computer to re-route MIDI back to the A800 at which point it will send its own keyboard and other events back out of its MIDI port. But this is a truly convoluted workaround. It never ever occurred to Roland that the MIDI channel on which the keyboard transmits should be stored as part of the 'control set' (i.e the individual patch map, of which you can store 20). You can assign a MIDI channel globally and another one to be used when another of those stupid dedicated keys is pressed (LOWER) but that's it. These channels affect all control sets. This makes controlling something like Hauptwerk's organs unnecessarily intricate, to say the least. Other minor annoyances are that managing setup changes from the keyboard itself are unnecessarily painful - you have to press two buttons simultaneously to go into edit mode - why, when so many other stupid functions have their own button, I don't know. And then navigate a convoluted menu system using the master control knob, with no obvious way of backing up one level if you go down the wrong path - you have to exit edit mode and start over. A more major shortcoming. All those buttons light up beautifully. Does the A800 therefore respond to MIDI ins and light the button up if you send back a MIDI message (as my BCR2000 controller does, for instance). Well, no. It doesn't. Why is that annoying. Well, I could have set it up so that when the transport is in PLAY mode the play button is lit and then when rewind is pressed, the play button goes out and rewind illuminates. That would have been easy. I could just have added a second copy of my full-duplex BCR2000 control surface plugin and had the controls send the appropriate CC messages. But, as I said, forget it. The A800 won't respond to any incoming MIDI messages - about all it can do is route them to its MIDI out, or of course, it accepts some of them as reprogramming messages from the PC-based software (which by the way is pretty good, at least, it seems to be solid and simple to use. Must have been a different team of developers....). A couple of last gripes. Roland couldn't be bothered adding support for MIDI MMC messages which most transports use. Now they are just SysEx messages and you can set them up, slowly and painfully, but this is annoying. And finally, the documentation. I love documentation that says 'Rotary Encoder Mode'. This mode sets up Rotary Encoder Mode for the control. Gosh!.... So, to summarise. It's very well made. It plays beautifully, albeit the aftertouch requires a fair bit of pressure The firmware and associated PC control software and the drivers seem reliable. After a good deal of head scratching and manual consultation, you can probably get it set up to do more-or-less what you want. I'm still pleased with it. It's the Least Worst option rather than the best though The design of the firmware sucks. I'm so baffled. Years ago I owned a Roland MV-30 all-in-one music studio. In one box it was a 16 track MIDI sequencer and a ROMpler. It was utterly intuitive to use. I loved it. So I can't understand how Roland can screw it up so badly. Still, it's useable. But only its mother could love it, I'm afraid....
post edited by aj - 2012/10/17 14:44:08
#1

5 Replies Related Threads

    Kenneth
    Max Output Level: -84 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 314
    • Joined: 2012/08/25 02:25:07
    • Location: Denmark
    • Status: offline
    Re:A user review of the A800 pro 2012/10/18 02:43:44 (permalink)
    "this is why separate mod and pitch wheels, in my opinion are inferior to a combined joystick"

    Could'nt agree more, vertical seperate mod and pitch wheels SUCK for very fast intricate vibrato control, and adding a bit of mod wheel at the same time as you are doing vibrato is almost impossible, doing this with a joystic type is so much easier.

    Also agreed on the aftertouch, takes way to much pressure even with it set as sensitive as possible.

    Couple of my gripes with it:

    Why do the act control button have to be activated for the transport buttons to work?

    Keyboard split both in split and dual mode is not part of the preset.. why?
    Pitch and mod wheel setup is not part of the preset.. why?


    i7 Sandy Bridge K2600 16Gb RAM 3x240GB Intel SSD | Samsung 40" LED Monitor | Win7 Pro 64bit | Saffire Pro 24 | Powercore MKII | Yamaha KX8 88 weighted  keys| 2 x Behringer BCR2000 | Octapad SPD30 | Yamaha NS10, Focal Solo 6 BE | Bryston 4B Yamaha p2200 Amps| Sonar X2+Quickfix | EWQLSO Gold | Stormdrum2 | 8DIO Almost everything | Omnisphere | Zebra2 | Prominy V-Metal, SC Guitar, SR5 Bass | VIR2 Electri6ty | Shreddage X | Amplitude 3 | BOME MIDI Translator, Autohotkey     
    #2
    aj
    Max Output Level: -69 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 1084
    • Joined: 2003/12/08 08:21:36
    • Status: offline
    Re: A user review of the A800 pro 2013/08/09 16:53:04 (permalink)
    I'll just add the super-annoying quirk that if you program a button to send a SysEx message, it seems to only get sent over the external MIDI port and not via USB. I'm sure Roland's engineers have a darn good reason for this apart from driving users insane, but I have no idea what that might be.
    #3
    Michaelcv
    Max Output Level: -90 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 1
    • Joined: 2014/12/21 19:39:52
    • Status: offline
    Re: A user review of the A800 pro 2015/07/08 06:55:55 (permalink)
    compre el producto roland a 800pro y lamentablemente en mi país Perú no cuenta con la tecnología, así que solicite a roland una información técnica, lamentablemente hasta hoy no e podido contactarme con ellos, así que espero ustedes que tienen mas conocimiento de este producto pediré su ayuda, quería utilizar el teclado con un ipad y con el software sonar x2 lamentablemente no e podido descargar por que no tiene en su pagina de apple, asique baje otro programa, el garagebang.... ahora cuando voy a instalar el ipad después de comprar algunos adaptadores resulta que no prende, pues falta un transformador que no viene con el teclado, tengo otro transformador pero no prende si supuesta mente trabaja a 9 voltios y lamentablemente no prende el bendito teclado.... y roland no contesta mis mensajes, saben si el producto solo trabaja con su transformador original o puedo utilizar otro transformando y si existe el programa sonar x2 para ipad ???? este tiene dos selectores uno es para seleccionar el uso de una pc y el transformador y el otro para el sistema midi o es que el sistema midi funciona directamente, de verdad no se que hacer aveces quiero hacerlo pedazos jajajaja espero me ayuden chau  
    #4
    Rob James G
    Max Output Level: -90 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 26
    • Joined: 2015/07/13 07:39:44
    • Status: offline
    Re: A user review of the A800 pro 2015/08/05 12:24:35 (permalink)
    A little note regarding the aftertouch. It is very stiff. However it gets easier when you know where the channel aftertouch strip is in relation to the keys.
    It is easier to get AT effects when pressing white keys somewhere near the middle and the black keys right at the end.
     
    #5
    cbarnabo
    Max Output Level: -90 dBFS
    • Total Posts : 16
    • Joined: 2014/12/20 23:15:12
    • Status: offline
    Re: A user review of the A800 pro 2016/01/16 10:41:46 (permalink)
    Another note on aftertouch (yes, I know how old this thread is!) - there's a thread out on GearSlutz that indicates there is a potentiometer to adjust the sensitivity of the aftertouch.  Does require a bit of disassembly to get to, but supposedly makes the aftertouch much more sensitive.  
     
    I don't have one of these myself - was considering it as a replacement for my Novation Impulse but (thank you for the thorough write-up, AJ!) it evidently suffers the same thing that drives me nuts on the Impulse - no way to light a button by sending CC back to it!  That feedback is important to me on some of the VSTs I control - I want the buttons on the keyboard to track the state of the toggles in the VST, especially when changing presets. 

    SONAR Platinum, Windows 10, Lenovo G505s laptop (AMD A10 2.50GHz, 8GB, 1TB HDD, Radeon HD 8650G), Tascam US-1800, Roland RD-2000, Novation Impulse-61 (not using Automap), Korg nanoKontrol2 (using AZSlow control surface integration), commonly used softsynths: VB3, Dimension Pro, SI-Electric Piano, Cakewalk TTS-1.  Recently retired Yamaha KX88
    #6
    Jump to:
    © 2024 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1