First, NONE OF US HERE are top flight Mixers or Producers...so our opinions don't mean a hill
of beans...while I DO greatly respect them....
I see so many bashing THIS plugin or THAT plugin, mostly from the standpoint of having a
"beef" with the Company (myself not excluded
), or because they can't get it to
work properly, etc... or trying to over-scientifically analyze what it's doing.
YET
in regards to the S-1, it is used by some of the VERY BEST Mixers and FOH Engineers in the business.
What it does to widen or narrow, and skew, the sound field is what makes it valuable..that is all.
IR is used by some of the BEST MIXERS in the business...
Renn Verb is used extensively in studio's around the world...
Manny's Reverb has a Bricasti Model...and it's less then $50 right now...
Yes Valhalla has nice reverbs...so does 112db, Eventide, Lexicon,
2CAudio, Phoenix, etc...
But you don't find very many TOP producers using Valhalla on their mixes...
not that it's not good enough, but they use the tools that they feel works
best for THEM.
The ToneLux Tilt and the Maag EQ's are used extensively in Studio's the world over...
Looking at a "CURVE" doesn't tell you the "SOUND" that comes from it....it gives you
a "visualization" of how the filters are effecting the frequencies....nothing more...
but that curve on a graph can NEVER show you "the sound".
We can "over-analyze" something...rather then appreciate it's characteristics for what they are.
Every plugin must serve some purpose to SOMEONE. YOU don't have to like it...but someone else might
LOVE IT and produce Grammy winning recordings with it.
Bottom line is this...
These are TOOLS. And one wrench DOES NOT fit all...be happy with what works for YOU...
and let other's be happy with what works for them, and stop the over-analyzing already...
Not everyone uses Snap-On....or Mac...or Craftsman...
MOJO is MOJO...so get on with it already....MAKE MUSIC, prove your
"expertise", and win some Grammy's....that's all I'm saying...and I say
it with all due respect...