Another thing that does not work in Melodyne Studio 4 with Cakewalk is the auto scroll button. Auto scroll works only for a while when you first open a project and over a short period of time auto scroll stops working and the auto scroll button in the lower right hand corner of Melodyne has no effect.
It is a curiosity as to whether if these problems are Cakewalk induced or if they are isolated to Melodyne Studio 4 alone. I tend to think Melodyne and Cakewalk have somehow fallen out of sync due to the Cakewalk updates "interruption".
For, if these were global problems with Melodyne it would stand to reason that a lot more people would be writing Melodyne about them, just a thought.
I have really liked the Cakewalk updates especially the ones related to Melodyne, particularly, the update that allowed comping of Melodyne takes. That feature is fantastic! I fear Melodyne integration has suffered from fast updates with Cakewalk and then neglect due to the interruption.
Please look into these anomalies.
There are also color issues with the contrast flickering back and forth from grey to white in Melodyne and the toolbar occasionally sticks to the screen when using the note splitting tool in conjunction with the right click mouse.
I have documented these bugs...
I have also put in a request to Melodyne to add "color blobs"...
They were on the fence about it... but maybe, I have convinced them to see the light.
It could be a feature that one could turn on or off.
When working with 14 vocal tracks in a 17 minute song, color is crucial or, one is clicking through 14 tracks searching for that elusive blob that is slightly off.
Keep the gray blobs but color integration with Cakewalk would be such a nice feature and it would sell a lot of Melodyne programs. I for one would upgrade immediately. I have been told by Celemony techies that color blobs is a much requested feature. :)
It would be nice if Cakewalk passed along track color settings to Melodyne and vise versa. :)
Another thing is that, Melodyne has no public forum... :(
I assume this is because so many people resent that artists use Melodyne to correct pitch and they are loud mouthed and stink up a forum with their bias...
If you do not like track tuning, don't listen...
Just try and make a song with autotune and see all the trolls come out of the woodwork and criticize your music...
They seem to forget their criticism when they are wagging their butt at the club to it.
Melodyne I am sure is fed up with the trolls who criticize their product and I don't blame them for not having a forum..
But it does hurt development of this great product as does the negativity by people who do not really understand that years ago pitch editing was used also but it was just not something that an average garage musician could afford.
Pitch editing was reserved to multi-million dollar studios who had 15 sound engineers and if you listen to old recordings of songs the entertainers were not spot on either.
Our memory of the past is better than the reality of the music really was.
I can pick out tuning problems in lots of "oldies but goodies".
They have mostly been fixed these days with remixing and remastering (with Melodyne and other tuning apps)... So there! :)
If you don't think that rewinding the tape and punching in a line 100 times is not also "cheating" well that is what they did way back when and no one complained about that... Or splicing in a word or syllable into a tape is not cheating... Where were all the purist critics back then?
post edited by RexRed - 2018/06/19 02:32:12