RE: Midi editing question
2006/06/18 23:47:39
(permalink)
Audio and MIDI are COMPLETELY different data. To refresh: Audio is actual sound waves recorded in (on) your computer. MIDI is simply a series of numerical values for various musical attributes such as 1) Which note was struck on your keyboard; 2) How hard it was struck; 3) Did you use the sustain pedal; 4) How long did you hold the note?; etc...
Thus, MIDI is in some ways far more flexible than audio in that you can edit all of these values, AND you can assign different sounds at different times, and never need to re-record the performance. On the other hand audio is more appropriate 1) for things that can't (as yet) be MIDI'd, like the human voice, acoustic guitar performances, live drum performances (including the sound of the acoustic drums), etc...
If you are using synths, then most of the time MIDI is the way to go. That was the wonder of MIDI when it first arrived on the scene in the early 1980s. The ability to record a performance with the synths being played as if there were a player on each one. No loss in recording quality, and no using up of precious audio tracks (when 24 was the norm).