Going on a sub woofer field trip tonight.

Don't get your ears to close.

 Really Mccue....how low can you go?

 
 
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

mike_mccue


I'm hoping for 11.

If bapu was here... mehbee 13.

 Congratulations! This could be the very lowest post of all time.

Wow! $22,000 - $26,000 for a subwoofer installation and purchase. This thing better feel good. Let us know what you thought of it.

How can it be really loud if no one can hear it?

The only one who has to know is you and the power company. :-)




One of the listed benefits of this rotary technology is that it uses a fraction of the power that a voice coil type driver requires to get to a useful SPL.

drewfx1

mike_mccue


I'm looking forward to seeing how low I can actually hear.

The problem is you need the signal to be really loud to hear it.

So you have to boost the sub's level to ridiculous levels for frequencies that low to be of any use. May not be of much use for music, but could be fun for making the room shake.

It's hard to call it infra sonics.

I just got back. We listened to a 4.09Hz test tone. I heard it and felt it. It's hard to call it infrasonic after you have heard it.

The house resonated at 8hz and the root tone was masked by the sound of shaking stuff.

At 4 hertz the house settled down and it was clear and well defined.

We listened to some cool moog synthesization recordings. A field recording of the caldera of an active volcano.

When we got to the markee feature movie sound design it seemed obvious that even the mixes that are notorious for thunderous low content were not prepared to take advantage of this play back technology. The result was a sense of detail and gracefulness with even the loudest deep frequency events.

I am sort of gobsmacked.


Speaking with Mr Thigpen was delightful. I could sort of keep up with his explanations of how the driver and the system works. He seemed very humble and open about the various limitations that must be balanced to make his design work and he had a great enthusiasm for sharing his insights.

It was pretty awesome. :-)


best regards,
mike 

He cuts off the output of the rotary woofer anywhere between 20 and 40 Hz, and indeed he explains that as he develops the SPL capability for the low notes using higher (but stabilized and consistent) velocities of the fan blades that the character of the upper frequency sound gets harsh.

The corollary is that he uses a traditional cone driver between 30 and 80 Hz and so it is running in a graceful place and isn't trying to go as low as some subs that sound like they are mushy.

The blend seemed really smooth. The lowest notes seemed to be made with ease.

It was the finest stereo or surround system I have ever heard.


I don't personally have an great interest in hearing explosives on film, but I am wildly interested in how "infra"sonics create a sense of mood, atmosphere, and sonic signature of ambient environments.

I am also a slut for crazy low bass and the idea that music can still push the creative envelope in that direction.

Most of the movies barely had any sub 30 content but the few that did were spectacular. Yet, I have heard many real explosions, and what I heard last night was just a far more vivid impression rather than a reenactment of *the real thing*

I always over do the kick drum on my mixes... cause I like it that way. :-) This system would have revealed that my kicks are infra sonic on most systems.

The moog stuff and the pipe organ stuff was very "musical" and suggested that musicians could definitely write for this playback technology.

I can see this slowly becoming a feature at the rave clubs, if that's what they call them these days.


I am also fascinated with the idea that sound is a temporal sculpture of sorts. When you feel and hear the 4 Hz... you know you just bumped into something. So I have an enthusiasm for an increasing awareness that sound is something we actually touch like a sculpture. It's 3d art that we can walk within. A speaker like this will make you aware.


Mosh knows what I mean. :-)


drew, I think you would have really enjoyed speaking with Mr Thigpen and I dare say that you would have been better prepared to consider some of the explanations than I was. I'm still thinking about some of the stuff hoping to have an ah-ha moment.



all the very best,
mike 

 mike_mccue


He cuts off the output of the rotary woofer anywhere between 20 and 40 Hz, and indeed he explains that as he develops the SPL capability for the low notes using higher (but stabilized and consistent) velocities of the fan blades that the character of the upper frequency sound gets harsh.

The corollary is that he uses a traditional cone driver between 30 and 80 Hz and so it is running in a graceful place and isn't trying to go as low as some subs that sound like they are mushy.

Ah. OK. Forgive me, I didn't read the specifics on the system. This is what you need to do to make it useful for a signal that doesn't only consist of super low stuff - crank up the super low stuff by a huge amount, comparatively. This is like EQing the crap out of it, so it falls more into the "I don't care if it isn't 1000% natural reproduction, but it sounds better to me" camp (full disclosure - I happen to fall into this camp).

I am also a slut for crazy low bass and the idea that music can still push the creative envelope in that direction. 

Most of the movies barely had any sub 30 content but the few that did were spectacular. Yet, I have heard many real explosions, and what I heard last night was just a far more vivid impression rather than a reenactment of *the real thing*

I always over do the kick drum on my mixes... cause I like it that way. :-) This system would have revealed that my kicks are infra sonic on most systems.

The moog stuff and the pipe organ stuff was very "musical" and suggested that musicians could definitely write for this playback technology.

The paper I got those last charts from might be interesting to you:
http://www.noiseandhealth.org/article.asp?issn=1463-1741;year=2004;volume=6;issue=23;spage=37;epage=57;aulast=Moller

But it suggests that infrasonics may not be useful for music:

The perceived character of the sound changes gradually with frequency. For pure tones the tonal character and the sensation of pitch decrease with decreasing frequency, and they both cease around 20 Hz. Below this frequency tones are perceived as discontinuous. From around 10 Hz and lower it is possible to follow and count the single cycles of the tone, and the perception changes into a sensation of pressure at the ears. At levels 20-25 dB above threshold it is possible to feel vibrations in various parts of the body, e.g. the lumbar, buttock, thigh and calf regions. A feeling of pressure may occur in the upper part of the chest and the throat region.

I wonder if your impressions were different than what they describe? 

I can see this slowly becoming a feature at the rave clubs, if that's what they call them these days. 

I am also fascinated with the idea that sound is a temporal sculpture of sorts. When you feel and hear the 4 Hz... you know you just bumped into something. So I have an enthusiasm for an increasing awareness that sound is something we actually touch like a sculpture. It's 3d art that we can walk within. A speaker like this will make you aware. 

I was thinking about things like amusement parks. But I wondered about possible hearing damage with sustained levels of infrasonics that might be over 120dB SPL. Did a quick google, but couldn't find anything that didn't appear to be purely speculative and sometimes completely different conclusions.

drew, I think you would have really enjoyed speaking with Mr Thigpen and I dare say that you would have been better prepared to consider some of the explanations than I was. I'm still thinking about some of the stuff hoping to have an ah-ha moment. 

Well, I might worry that we might offend one another, me being a skeptic and all. But I am in favor of "more bass". And it goes without saying that I would love to play an extended range bass through a system like that! 

 
 Hopefully the price will be really LOW.

"You shake my nerves and you rattle my brain!!!"
 
This is real rock and roll, I want one of these.
 
I need it to complete my Symphony in Am for Foghorns.  The overture is just not working right now.  I'm sure this will fix it.
 
Then it's just a case of waiting for the correct air temperature, dew point and sea conditions and I'm going to be golden.
 
Thank goodness, I never thought I'd see the day that I could finish this piece but this changes everything.
 
I'll whack it up on SoundCloud when I'm done.

 
I just found these:
 
 

 

 

musicman100


errr, can you repeat that, Strummy???

 
Sorry George....
 
 
But I can't.

If I only had a purpose...or wuz won...