RE: Good way to compose drum parts?
2008/01/28 23:22:42
(permalink)
I've never used patterns at all, except sometimes as something temporary while I'm building the rest of the parts. It seems to me that a drum part constructed of even quite a few patterns would be rather uninteresting. Although I'm certainly no drummer, I lay down the drum parts myself.
I do have some drum pads, but I usually find myself using a keyboard and input the MIDI that way. First I go through the entire song and just lay down the kick and snare - nothing else. But I concentrate on doing something interesting, just thinking about how those two drums work with the bass part and any other "interesting" rhythm stuff I have going on. After I've gone through the entire song, I go back and fix up the inevitable goofs that I put in there. Then I listen through and make sure I'm happy with just the kick and snare playing along with the rest of the parts.
After that I'll play through the whole song and put in nothing but tom fills, making them do something interesting but not overbearing to work with what's already there. Then I finally go through and fill in the cymbals and whatever else may be useful to the song.
Next, I mute everything except for the drums and listen to the whole song. This is the time to listen for things that don't work well together and to clean them up. I also listen for things that sound too busy and try to make it sound as much as possible like something a real drummer would/could have done. When it's done right, the drum part should be interesting in its own right without being too overwhelming and "showy".
Finally, I listen to all of the parts together and fine-tune. It may take several listens to get something that's kind of decent. Then I shut down and come back the next day, making sure I still like what I did, and cleaning up whatever doesn't make me a bit giddy.
Of course, this is not a fast process. For an eight-minute song, it can take several hours to arrive at something I like, and it will likely evolve over the next week or so. But it's a satisfying process and I'm not in any hurry. And when it's all said and done, it's the best way for a wanna-be drummer like to lay down something that makes me think, "Wow - what a cool drum part!"