Help me with a Leslie sim shootout?

HI Bit,
 
I have PSP L'Otary and Plug n Mix LS Rotator which I could try for you if that's of interest?
 

Thanks to Zinc Trumpet for offering to help out. Anyone else?

As you know, I've got the IKM Leslie Collection (and you have my email address).  Happy to help out.

My Line 6 POD Farm 2 has two Leslie simulators. 
1. Rotary Drum
2. Rotary Drum plus horn
 
I've never used either one so I can't say how they are.  But I've used other POD Farm amp and bass sims and reverb and delay and they are very good.
 

http://mda.smartelectronix.com/
 
their one is open source ?
 
I do have "MVintageRotary" by melda and the ik / psp ones
 

bitflipper
 
ZT, I have the full GR5 (5.2.2) but don't see a Leslie listed there. Could I be out of date, or was that an optional component? Or maybe I'm just not seeing it - what's it called?
 

Look in the modulation category for "Rotator"

Hey Bit, I recently picked up GG Audio Spin, but can't say I'm much of an expert on rotary sounds.  I can help out by running the file through some presets or something, but this thing has a lot of options. (I got it bundled with the Organ they have, which was more of a priority for me than a Leslie.)

bitflipper
I've already done MVintageRotary and L'otary

Ironically, when I Googled this before, those were the only two that got mentioned in many posts.

I've been tempted every time MRotary comes up on the 50% off list, but it seemed redundant with the great Leslie sims I've already got, including MVintageRotary. 
 
Then again, it might be cool to try a glass speaker cabinet. I think I'll leave it out of this particular demonstration, though, because it's not specifically a Leslie emulator.

Will do. Thanks.

You'll notice that none of these Leslie sims mention the name "Leslie" at all. That's a trademarked brand name owned by Suzuki. Hence the imaginative allegories such as "Spin" and "Rotor".
 
Properly simulating the rotary speaker electronically or digitally has proven to be elusive. It is an acoustical effect, meaning it happens in air. Just putting a microphone on a real Leslie gives you an entirely different experience than hearing a Leslie interact with the room with your own ears.
 
I have a hardware unit called the Ventilator that does a very good job, but you'd never confuse it with the sound of a real Leslie. Likewise for the pretty good Leslie that's built in to VB3, or the very nice-sounding MVintageRotary. 

bitflipper
You'll notice that none of these Leslie sims mention the name "Leslie" at all. That's a trademarked brand name owned by Suzuki. Hence the imaginative allegories such as "Spin" and "Rotor".
 
Properly simulating the rotary speaker electronically or digitally has proven to be elusive. It is an acoustical effect, meaning it happens in air. Just putting a microphone on a real Leslie gives you an entirely different experience than hearing a Leslie interact with the room with your own ears.
 
I have a hardware unit called the Ventilator that does a very good job, but you'd never confuse it with the sound of a real Leslie. Likewise for the pretty good Leslie that's built in to VB3, or the very nice-sounding MVintageRotary. 

The one from Ik is officialy endorsed , nope ?

I've just dug out the MDA Leslie and reinstalled it. The DLL file's datestamp is 2002 and I don't think that it has ever been updated. Anyway I tried it but the GUI would not display properly and I was not able to change any of the parameters from the default settings.