When you use it in subtract mode, by default it works as the noise elimination. Depending from the noise level, that can significantly change the signal as well, up to making it very bad.
But before you move to other solutions, are you sure you have applied it correctly? You need to play a recording with noise only and automatic build profile option set. And then unset that option. If it was on even a part of a second when real signal was played, the plug-in will eliminate that signal from the whole recording.
Listen this video for expected results:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31phzT7pxkkI use it for speech without adjustments, but my noise level is low. In the tutorial, manual adjustment is demonstrated. Unfortunately, it is not accessible. But you can try to do the same. The graph is a big area under build profile option. So if you position mouse to that option and move it by hand a bit lower, it will be there. NVDA say "ReaFIR" when that area is reached after it was over the option. With ctrl pressed, click and drag up and down.
Alternatively, you can rise the track gain after building the profile. I think the effect should be similar.