this is my response:
 
This is a version of Badinerie i programed today. It is not others work other that Bach himself who wrote the work. But I am really flattered that you think my programming with the sound of IK-Multimedia - Miroslav Philharmonik 2, is as good as an live recording of an orchestra. I am humbled by that.
 
And If the Original recording would be authentic to Baroque Music, it would not be recorded in A=440 Hz, but rather lover down towards 415.30 Hz that is G# something your algorithm should pick up.
 
A Baroque recording should not be in 440 Hz. But for noobs like me, we do, because we uses sampled instruments like the IK-Multimedia - Miroslav Philharmonik 2, Native Instruments Symphony Series and so on. Those takes time to retune to a authentic tuning as the Baroque music should have.
 
But thank you again, for saying it is as good as the real deal.

LOL!

Shirley they're Baching up the wrong tree....good for you though.
Post it on Youtube, it may go viral.

The guys only been dead 400 years, you would think his stuff is in the public domain. Check those algorhythms...

he's got damn good lawyers.

I wouldn't have even entertained those morons. I would have simply told them to put it back up because it is my own production of a work that is in the public domain.

Interesting choice.  Is he making a comebach?
 

Interesting topic...
 
Found the article below regarding derivatives (copyrighted arrangements) of public domain music that MAY be copyrighted:
 
Avoiding problems with public domain music
http://www.publicdomainsh...blic-domain-music.html

Inclined to have some fun with the copyright police? 
 
Here is a free sheet music website, all in the Public Domain, or under Creative Commons licenses.  http://www.mutopiaproject.org/
 
Available in PDF or MIDI file formats.  Lots of old classical stuff here!  > http://www.mutopiaproject.org/collections.html
 
 

abacab
Found the article below regarding derivatives (copyrighted arrangements) of public domain music that MAY be copyrighted:
 
Avoiding problems with public domain music
http://www.publicdomainsh...blic-domain-music.html

In a similar vein, back in '87 I was contracted to record 5 of my own originals songs for a national radio program. I was paid for doing it, and they played each song 5 times and 5 times only.  If they were to play them after that, I'd have to receive more royalties.  So they've sat in the vault (or erased?) for over 30 years now, unplayed.
 
However...
 
From the start, I've never been allowed to shop those recordings around to other stations, nor use them on any albums I make, nor post them online - even if it's non-profit.
I do own the songs, and have complete copyright on them, but the radio network owns those versions that were recorded for their program.  I can re-record them, even if I do them exactly as before, but those particular versions are theirs, and I can't touch them.
 
Copyright is a strange land to navigate.