Sonar Platinum
Line 6 UX2
 
Let's say I record a guitar track and insert a guitar plugin such as TH3 or POD Farm in the FX Bin.  It's working fine.  Then I record another guitar track and insert the same plugin in the second track's FX Bin.  However, the second track will have different components than the first track.  My problem is that when I play over the second track it will also be playing the components of the first track.  I've tried putting them on separate buses but that didn't help.

Set the input on the first track to NONE and turn off input monitoring.

What Bob said ^^^
 
I was trying to post a link to Input Monitoring, but it was getting chopped off....
 
Just need to look up Input Monitoring at the Cake website.

That did it!  Thanks!