This comment caught my eye and made another question come to mind...
Sidroe
As a guitarist for almost 50 years I can attest to the fact that NOTHING beats a really good tube guitar amp with the classic dynamic or condenser mic placed correctly.
25 years ago, when I first started playing guitar, research showed that pedals (granted hardware) could not replicate true tube amp sounds so I opted to get a nice Carvin tube amp. At that time "MOSFET technology" was coming onboard, but not mature, although looked promising to replicate a tube amp sound in the future...
Granted, stomp boxes/pedal boards are hardware, but I was curious if you feel they can replicate a tube amp nowadays? I never tracked the MOSFET hype since I would never need it, but it is now 25 years after the fact (ugh).
I also agree in two things 100% regarding amp sims... 1) the convenience of them and 2) the ability to alter the sound
drastically during the mixing phase since the clean tone is what is actually recorded. Even new applications like Melodyne do not take well to being fed a distorted signal.