• SONAR
  • Selection bug (p.2)
2016/04/21 16:37:44
stickman393
Nice repro!
 
2016/04/21 16:48:16
mettelus
Okay, so scratch the folder idea.
 
Here is a video of deselection at the end of a process (I used a simple transpose), no tracks are re-selected with an expanded range. I also redid similar with it zoomed out so I could select the entire project in the timeline from right to left, and no re-selection occurred.
 
2016/04/21 16:50:49
Anderton
Anderton
Now, THAT for sure is a bug.

 
Or actually, maybe not...?
 

 
 
 
2016/04/21 17:01:41
Anderton
mettelus
Okay, so scratch the folder idea.
 
Here is a video of deselection at the end of a process (I used a simple transpose), no tracks are re-selected with an expanded range. I also redid similar with it zoomed out so I could select the entire project in the timeline from right to left, and no re-selection occurred.

 
But you didn't do a process and extend the region per WC, you created a new one. Again, if you don't believe me, I'll do a video that shows how extending a range automatically re-selects the track/clip once it encounters one. That's what I was talking about because that's what [I thought] he was describing.
 
In the future, I should probably just refrain from trying to answer a WC post until I see the translations.
 
2016/04/22 00:51:22
williamcopper
To add to the OP, and clarify the unfortunately ambigious term "extend the selection" -- I typically use 'select by time', and have it set to a keyboard shortcut.    So that is how I "extended the selection":   called up "select by time", and changed the end time to a different time, further out.    This is not anything special for this process, it is how I nearly always work with selected bars.  
2016/04/22 03:02:17
azslow3
Anderton
Anderton
Now, THAT for sure is a bug.

 
Or actually, maybe not...?
 


In your video all 3 tracks have all 3 clips.
 
In my example the second clip has no second clip and that is triggering the bug - empty spaces bugging selections.
2016/04/22 03:09:51
jb101
azslow3
In my example the second clip has no second clip and that is triggering the bug - empty spaces bugging selections.


Huh?
2016/04/22 04:00:36
williamcopper
I believe Aslow intended to say, the second Track has no clips, not the second Clip has no clips.
2016/04/22 04:19:18
mettelus
+1, in aslow3's example, the second track does not have the second clip in it, so when it is processed, SONAR drops track 2 from the selected group. Then when the third clip set is highlighted, track 2 is no longer processed.
 
It essentially replicates the OP better, since the tracks are "out of view," so the user is none-the-wiser that their selection has been altered.
2016/04/22 04:23:41
Kylotan
I've seen various problems like this in other contexts, where Sonar changes the selection based on what it found inside it, instead of preserving the area I wanted to have selected. It makes predictable operations impossible in many cases.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account