I opened a support ticket at Focusrite, so I'll let you know what they advise. I did find these instructions for completely removing the Focusrite drivers over at the Avid forum. They are from a Focusrite support tech:
1) With the Scarlett connected please open the Control Panel > System > Device Manager. Locate the Scarlett under Sound, Video and Game Controllers section.
2) Right click the Scarlett and choose Uninstall. Make sure to check the box to remove software for the device.
3) You will see the unit disappear from the list. Unplug the unit and plug it back in. It should reappear in the list.
4) Repeat steps 2 and 3 until the Scarlett appears with a yellow exclamation mark, and/or the properties says Code 10. The Properties > Driver tab will likely say a Microsoft driver is in use. This means all the drivers are removed.
5) Next go to Control Panel > Uninstall a Program. Uninstall any Focusrite USB Audio Driver, Scarlett Family Audio Drivers or Scarlett MixControl you find here.
6) All Focusrite drivers are now removed. Please reinstall the MixControl software and/or driver for the unit.