• SONAR
  • The LANDR Thread (p.28)
2016/03/02 02:02:21
Kamikaze
Wrong Thread
2016/03/02 03:26:44
tenfoot
skinnybones lampshade
Okay, this is the first song I've ever shared .... it's one of my own, mastered on the low setting by LandR.  I don't have a before and after right now but if you're interested I could supply the before (yes, this IS the after). Please don't rip me apart .. I hope the link works.
https://soundcloud.com/laura-thomson-723335445/dropbox-landr-pedal-faster


Nice Laura - thanks for posting that!  Fun, Sweet and quirky. For some reason it made me think of the movie 'Cinema Paradiso'.
 
Were you happy with the changes Landr made?
https://www.google.com.au...mgrc=IdlaSa64c9an_M%3A
2016/03/02 07:30:38
Jesse Screed
I know I'm just learning my craft, and the cheeseburger analogy with the Seinfeld/Kramer reference that I made in an earlier post was probably lost on evryone.
 
But I will say this.  Everything I read about mastering says that a good master is dependent on a good mix.  Also. everything I read about a good mix says that mixing is "subjective."  I have also heard it said that mastering is subjective.  Then, folks keep talking about using reference mixes, and folks who master say that they like it when an artist tells them which CD, or other artist, they would like to sound like.  Then Jimmy alludes that LANDR is genre dependent So what in the heck are we talking about?
 
So, I'm not averse to LANDR. I do want to be able to install it or not, which Bapu has shown there are ways to avoid installing it in CCC.  If people want to use it, and they get a good result, fine.  If a pro uses it for a down and dirty rough master, fine.  Will it ever replace a pro mastering engineer, maybe in the future, but robots will eventually replace everyone.  I remember Bit saying that a plugin will never replace good old hands on wave editing, and where the technology is right now, I have to agree with him.
 
For me, I choose to practice mixing and mastering, and to get better at it using my ears.  But it's all subjective right?
 
LANDR is not good or bad in essence, at least in my opinion.   So there, I'm done...another use of bandwidth in the cacophony of the LANDR thread.
 
Jesse Q. Screed
 
"nature does not hurry, yet all is accomplished"
2016/03/02 07:47:52
jerrydf
Never mind LANDR - I just heard Laura Thomson's track Pedal Faster
https://soundcloud.com/laura-thomson-723335445/dropbox-landr-pedal-faster
That's really good.
 
jdf 
2016/03/02 08:44:59
learsfool
Laura (skinnybones lampshade),
Pedal Faster is a fantastic song in so many ways. If LANDR aided the final product, I'm sold. Thank you for sharing.
2016/03/02 10:20:02
Jimmy Landry [Cakewalk]
Anderton
Jimmy Landry [Cakewalk]
A few folks mentioned they would like to see more Landr examples so I posted 5 masters of the same song to a SoundCloud Playlist.  One of them is the actual master on the record by a well known facility (and guy) here in NYC that mastered the record, another is the original that I handed off to him.

https://soundcloud.com/cakewalksoftware/sets/landr-test-1



Very interesting...but what would have been more interesting is if you hadn't identified which was which, and asked people to rate them from "liked the least" to "liked the most." The takeaways would be 1) determining if one particular mastering "style" was a hands-down favorite, and 2) whether people could tell which were LANDRed and which weren't.




Stop coming up with great interesting ideas!!!  I have another track on the record and will carve some time to do that.  THAT will be interesting...
2016/03/02 15:14:59
stxx
It doesn't matter what was what.   What matters if LANDR sounds good or not and LANDR sounds good. I use it all the time and have used all settings at one time or another and it sounds better than some mastering engineers I have used for 10x the cost.
2016/03/02 15:44:48
Beepster
It's only been a few days but if and when the review of the installer concerns has been completed I (and I'm sure many others) would like to hear what the final word is one way or the other.
 
Not trying to rush a decision. Just want to know when a decision has been made and what the outcome was.
 
Thanks.
2016/03/02 16:46:29
skinnybones lampshade
Thank you very much, Scott, Jerry and Ludlow for your kind words and for your encouragement. You really made my day!
LJ
2016/03/03 03:28:32
JoseC.
jb101
Don't worry, Steve, he is back again, with yet another alternate login.

He'll pop in here soon, no doubt.


At first I had read "He'll poop in here soon"...
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account