I see now that what appeared in my Audition window was the selected portion of the underlying wav with the rest 'offscreen' to left and right.
Here's something I just tried. Unlike sharke's example of sending the beginning portion of a clip, I used a section contained in the middle of a clip.
1. select the region of interest in Sonar then split it at both ends
2. select the new clip and invoke Audition on it
3. immediately hit Trim in Audition (proper region is already selected) to discard the extra wav on both sides
4. do what you have to do in Audition
[Now all we'd need would be to close Audition and have the new wav in Audition replace the new clip in Sonar and not replace the entire wav of the original clip with the new piece as it does now.]
5. still in Audition, Save As a new file (the "Tool copy n" gets automatically incremented)
6. close Audition, Sonar does not ask anything as it would have if I hadn't Saved As new wav within Audition
7. in Sonar, delete the split-out clip
8. import the wav saved in Audition into the space vacated by the clip (it fits perfectly)