The CPU socket bent pin excuse is not limited to newegg. According to a post on the Windows 7 forum from a user in Australia they are having the same issue with Australian component sellers. After I got the motherboard back from newegg, I examined the CPU socket with a magnifying glass and could not see any bent pins.
I didn't make a big issue with newegg over my motherboard, since AS Rock made good on it, but I did write newegg off for future purchases. Which brings up another issue, AS Rock support told me to contact the seller to get it replaced as it was less than 30 days from when I got it from newegg. If they would have told me to send it directly to them initially, after they diagnosed (actually confirmed what I already knew) the two memory slot problems, newegg would have never been involved.