Beagle
you do realize that ANY home theater speakers are going to sound a LOT better than studio monitors, right? they're designed for different purposes. Studio monitors are supposed to have a flat response and so they will not sound as good as home theater speakers which are designed for listening pleasure.
I know this is something of an article of faith for many people but really, there is little evidence of it. Good speaker design is good speaker design. When speakers are designed for linear response, good controlled dispersion, low distortion, etc they sound good and are neutral and good to use for production. You find B&Ws in plenty of high end studios (like
Abbey Road for instance). Comparing those graphs isn't easy since they are on different scales and using different measurement techniques (unspecified in the second one), and it isn't specified which crossoves the M series had (they changed them part way through their life and enhanced things a lot, and owners could send their back for free to have it upgraded). All that aside I have accurate graphs from SVS (I got all that before I tried them) and they are pretty flat in a measurement room, within 2dB. Not so in my room, of course.
The issue was that really I heard very little difference. The Scepters had much less bottom end, of course, since it was small 2-way vs tower, but other than that it was real "meh". The thing I was told would blow my pants off was imaging and that was just the same. The SVS speakers produce a wide, solid, convincing soundstage and so did the Scepters. Over all the detail and mids/highs were about on par. Slightly different sound, but not enough for me to call a winner, or to care.
I also decided to give them the benefit of a better room. My computer room is a small boxy spare bedroom. So I took the Scepters out in to my greatroom which is very large, has sloped ceilings, set them on stands out in the middle of the room and away from the wall and gave them a listen. They were fine, but I wasn't impressed. I mean if I didn't already have good speakers they'd be contenders, but I did.
So back they went.
that is a problem; they shouldn't do that. are you certain you didn't have a defective set?
Searching online it seems to be a common complaint. The amps just aren't very quiet. They put out noise in somewhere in the realm of 15-25dBSPL. That's not a lot, but I can hear it in my room. I don't know how quiet the room is, my cheap dB meter only goes down to 28dB, but it is quieter than that.
Again I might have looked at a solution to the hiss had I been more impressed, but given that I wasn't I just sent them back.
So in general I'm thinking I need to look higher end, hence why I'm looking at a budget of around $3000. I'm hopeful that will provide an improvement, since I'd like that as well as being able to relocate the speakers on to my desk, rather than behind it.