Anderton
brconflict
But I'd think Sonar would benefit from at least some form of choice in fader/meter height based on even simpler form. For example, when you change the scale of the meter in console view, perhaps, instead of sacrificing the lower levels of the meter, simply expand the size of the meter and fader to a greater height.
I think the issue with most DAWs is the paradigm of hardware emulation. For example, I've often thought that software faders might be better as vertical arcs, so you would have much more fader travel in the same amount of height. Inside the arc, you could have mute, solo, pan, and a "short form" version of the channel processing with a fly-out for more detail (similar to how the ProChannel works in Console View). The channel strips would be wider, but they would also be shorter, so you could have rows of faders stacked above each other...that sort of thing...of course it may or may not be useable in practice, but we need to break out of "hardware thinking." As another example, if a channel goes into the red, why not have the entire fader turn red instead of a little "virtual LED"?
Although the classic hardware look was one of the main reasons I chose Sonar (ease of view), and I still miss the X1 Light color scheme, which was classy, I wouldn't dispute an abstraction from the hardware look/feel. I won't do Duckbar, but I would welcome some other options natively. I think there's a balance. Even PT has a rigid, dim look/appeal to it with old colors that people just recognize vs. appeal to. Albeit these are both easy-to-view screens.
But much like Cakewalk allows you now to expand the FX bin and Sends areas, it might not be the most difficult thing to apply this type of change to the fader boxes. That's my hope, anyway.
To add to the whole fader turning red, why not a heat-detection in the meter or fader, where it starts glowing orange like the eye of a stove when the signal is averaging hot, then "pop smoke" for an over my illuminating an LED on the fader itself or turning the fader red vs. Orange. I like the idea of getting your attention with an over, though. Certainly would make it more (usefully) annoying to endure vs. a tiny LED.