Just mess around with a dedicated bus you send everything to for the desired time range using things like EQ, tape sims, exaggerated compression settings, tube and tape saturation and things that introduce "noise".
Put it in the FX Bin of the bus and automate it all for that momentary effect (you could do this a send automation so everything goes to that bus for the desire time while the main track is silenced).
If you look at the Blue Tubes suite there is an effect that has year based settings that works well for throwback stuff. The old Cakewalk Tape Sim has a "Noise" feature that introduces some scratchiness. A lot of EQ's will have a "telephone" preset that yanks out a ton of lows and makes things sound very lofi (and you can create this effect manually if you google Telephone Effect EQ).
There are of course third party plugs that can do this instantly but yanno... you might have to pay and since it's not that hard to do with what is already included in Sonar so it's just a matter of how much it's worth to you to get this effect versus learnign to create it on your own.
Ideally though I'd imagine you'd want some kind of Vinyl Emulator effect if you were going third party.
Just some thoughts.
CHeers.
Edit: Just remembered the Blue Tubes plug... It's the Oilcan Reverb and it actually does a pretty good job at just automatically creating a vintage lofi sound BUT I would personally do some other stuff to really nail the effect. Check it out. It might get you most of the way where you want to go.