Guys, thanks much for the input... in case you're interested.....
Tried a whole bunch of suggestions, but nothing seemed to appeal to my ears. The PC stuff in Sonar just sounds too phony to my ears for this purpose. The BT Analog Valvedriver ADR-2S seemed to do some of it, but was too intrusive it seemed. I kept thinking that re-amping would do the trick, so I just tried a few guitar amp plugins for the heck of it, and Poulin Lextac seems to get pretty close to what I'm after... not spot on yet, but just off the cuff I can dial in a PA-like tone with variable grit / distortion that's not too bad. Puts a different spin on the vocal track.
Amplitude free didn't seem to have what I was after either.