Hi kitekrazy1,
I have a TC Impact Twin, MOTU Traveler 1st gen, and MOTU Traveler Mk3. They all work fine in Windows 7, 8 and 8.1. I use whatever the usual non-legacy Firewire driver that is being used. I have also tried the legacy driver, it makes no difference whatsoever in compatibility. I think the legacy driver is a bit slower, but that could just be my imagination.
My Dell laptop has a Ricoh chipset using the Ricoh 1394 driver. Folks on the web swear up and down that Ricoh is crap and gives them endless grieves, mine just seems OK. My other Fujitsu laptop doesn't have Firewire built in, but it does have an ExpressCard slot. I put in a StarTech Firewire card (TI chipset) into the slot, and again I don't have any issues.
At one time I had lots of issues with getting the Firewire devices to work. Either Windows would not detect them, or BSOD quickly when I started using them. I eventually tracked it down to a bad cable. After the cable was replaced, it was all good.
So perhaps I'm just being lucky with Firewire, but then I have never tried any of the brands in your list. That said, if I were to continue using Firewire, it looks like the only option left is Thunderbolt (or ExpressCard slot, but that's rare and performance is not ideal). Someday I would probably switch over to USB, just not now though as my Firewire devices are still working.