Wow, what a thread full of insights! At 64 I've been a singer/songwriter since the early "Elvis" days when I was a little kid... I can so relate to literally EVERY post above...and have huge GAS pains I try to control...(yea, like just buying infinity and gravity... good goin' dude!). I've gone through the overloading songs insanity. I've relegated most of my plugins/synths/effects to the dustbin these days... should sell um I guess.
My favorite artist is Rush... do so much with so little... exquisitely crafted words and messages, minimally saturated music but everything shines with an expressive sense of urgency, emotion and POWER!...They have several dozen songs which routinely bring me to tears. They've moved thru the ages and evolution of tech yet have not lost the power and simplicity in what they do. Just brilliant what those three humans create.
I'm now at the point of reassessing everything. I've shifted to evernote for songwriting whereever and whenever the inspiration hits. The perfect combo of tech and primitive language. I have no more, "where'd the f'in' words go"... they're everywhere, on my phone, in the cloud, on the vastmaschine...
I'll often come up with a melody along with a message and it's generally the best as it arrives in that creative moment, whether while working in the garden or.... so I have phone aps to capture it. Have even started using google translator to capture song thoughts way faster than I can type or write.
I think the old way forced us to come up with a whole idea or framework/foundation...and is important to remember, as endless options nowadays can be a distraction if we let it...it is addicting! I do miss the band practices/song writing sessions where multiple influences co-join into something unique and squirting it into my various Tascam's or later, ADAT was the goal.
My struggle these days is I am a naturally intuitive artist, whether in garden design or composition... and many of my recent songs start out as just playing around with something like BFD3 and Stratosphere or some Kontakt library... Yet I know that just sitting down with the acoustic guitar and working out a song generally results in a more cohesive effort.
But this era of DAW/VST/CPU power is friggin' amazing. I'm soooo glad I'm here. To wield such power that heretofore never existed is orgasmic...