2015/05/02 20:23:23
PhilP
Will Cake introduce something similar to expression maps in SPlat? I am also curios to know how other EW users are handling articulations / editing within SPlat.
 
Cheers,
 
Phil
2015/05/03 05:52:53
Bristol_Jonesey
I created about 37 different drum maps for handling Artics, each one dedicated to a particular instrument, or in the case of percussion, groups of instruments.
2015/05/03 06:15:27
PhilP
Bristol_Jonesey
I created about 37 different drum maps for handling Artics, each one dedicated to a particular instrument, or in the case of percussion, groups of instruments.




Thanks Bristol Jonesey - I have to look into using drum maps, I know scook does it this way as well. At present I am just loading each articulation as a separate instrument which is a pain when editing. I know my method is pretty basic and I'm keen to learn better alternatives.
 
Cheers,
 
Phil 
2015/05/03 09:23:38
gbar
I wish they would do something like VST expression.  I have had to talk myself out of switching DAWs about once a month for the last 18 months or so.
 
Drum maps should work for key switching only.
 
Won't help you UACC and other things that use CCs for selecting articulations (and if you ask me, this is a potentially better solution than key switching because... it still works if you loop a piece you are working on after the CC is changed, but key switching goes haywire if your loop starts after the note on for the key switch, plus key switching just wrecks notation unless you put it on another track and feed it to your instrument track or something)
2015/05/03 09:46:27
wst3
I too started down that Drum Map path, but found it too limiting.
 
My fantasy solution, and I am getting closer, is the ability to physically trigger articulation changes with key switches, but transform them to CC messages on the way in and send that CC message to Kontakt or Vienna Instrument or whatever, and record it as such.
 
Two primary reasons:
  1. CC messages can be chased, as just mentioned above, which is a big benefit for me.
  2. CC messages do not appear in the keyboard range of the PRV, nor do they clutter up notation (I use Finale for my notation needs.)
As an added benefit, while CC switches can be triggered from an external device with enough buttons (the Kore 2 has 8 buttons, which is proving to be insufficient in some cases), it is easier for me to use the keyboard keys, for now.
 
There are literally dozens of Kontakt scripts that provide conversion between CC and MIDI Note Number, but that limits one to Kontakt. Transmidifier is a stand-alone tool that can do all sorts of filtering and conversion, I've tried to get it to work as a single solution, but I'm not quite clever enough yet. Bidule is another candidate, and there are scripts available that do the magic.
 
Mostly it comes down to integrating one of these solutions, and thus far that has proven to be non-trivial. It becomes even more "interesting" if you use Spitfire UACC<G>!
 
I have experimented with a couple different iPad controller apps, and this might prove to be pretty cool, but right now I end up spending more time focusing on the iPad than the music, so that's not working<G>.
 
Of course that only addresses articulation switching - a major component of working with virtual instruments, but not everything. And in this case the CC messages are used as switches, that is, some small range of values represents each articulation.
 
The other thing I'd dearly love to see is better drawing tools for adding continuous controller data to the PRV. The current approach makes it difficult to draw something like Expression, or even volume in. I can record the controller itself, and often resort to that, but that isn't always as effective as just drawing the curve in COULD be.
 
Neither of which requires all the functions in Expression Maps - and I too have looked longingly at that other sequencer. But the cost, in $ and time, still outweighs the benefits for me.
© 2026 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account