Lord Tim
I made a mention of something similar here:
http://forum.cakewalk.com/m/tm.aspx?m=3200548
Excellent post! I agree with all you said. I miss the customization from the old days. It seemed to me when they embarked on this less clutter approach, they could have had the default install very uncluttered, but retained the customization for long time users that have preferred to choose their own level of so called clutter.
My 8.5 is more streamlined than Platinum, because I only have things displayed that I use all the time, the other stuff is hidden from view. In fact I wish in Platinum we could choose what each module displays. I'd trim some things off some modules and then I'd have plenty of room for modules that I can't view without using those arrow buttons.
The custom module is a start, but it's so limited. It's only buttons, no displays, or meters. The S/M/L sized modules is a step in the right direction for sure.
I love to see your idea of the "show us the current state" module where you'd have icons that show what you've set up like scroll lock or pause key being pressed, auto crossfades, and of course sound on sound, overwrite, etc
Brilliant!