John
Though the idea of a channel strip that is exclusive to a particular DAW is a concern its also true that as with Logic none of its FX were transferable to any other DAW. Nor are Cubase's FX. The idea of using third party FX is for this purpose a good one but its only one consideration. If you had a fully populated PC and you had spent enough time using it with all its possibilities you may have a very different view about its value.
Good to hear nobody was offended, it wasn't meant to.
Each daw has by tradition created stuff to lock users into their realm, kind of.
That's where my idea came from - don't ever use what is shipped with a daw - it will lock you in, not give you freedom for creativity.
Sonar PC was probably a forerunner to Softube Console 1. SC1, which also had fully integrated hardware to go with it. Very simple but efficient idea - fast access to a tracks strip. No previous/next stupidity - directly get to the track of concern. Brilliant approach. But overpriced - just being an SSL channelstrip plugin and a $200 hardware controller - $1100 is overpriced in my view. I payed $300 for Waves SSL 4000 - so $500 would be fair as I see it.
I never fully looked at Roland VS-xxxx systems how they do. They have flunked terribly marketing it if it really matches what SC1 do.
I have no doubt about the value of PC - but it locks me in - don't want that.
I spent all money on Waves for effects - good consistent gui, good A/B testing on every plugin, good preset handling without looking all over disk for what you saved, built in help on every plugin. When I've grown out of those and know them well, what they do to different music material - mixes probably sound ok too by then.
When you strike issues with stability, or lack of functionality to finalize an idea - you raise to a certain level of anger. If on top of that, you locked yourself into the daw in question - then that feeling will take a basketball team of poets to describe - furious is not anywhere near.
As it is now - I can move stuff in a couple of hours to another daw and continue there. First level of anger goes down to normal calm feel and being in control again. So it's basically a pill to stay sain - to have this flexibility. I can be moody, and Cake forum have had it's share of that, sadly enough.
But I'm really fond of Sonar. Sonar 4 Studio was perfect really no built in stuff on tracks, but going x64 S8.5 was the step to take. X3 and Sonar Artist - wow, it really makes me want to sit all days running it - and I will. It's a joyride, really.
I'm pleased with answers I got here about PC - so have no hesitation to move to SProf or SPlat - if something profound arrive. Mission accomplished, I'm on track...