Are you adding a second track for the second pass?
Each track has an input and an output. Do both tracks have the same input (set one of them to 'none').
are both tracks armed (small red button on track)? if so, turn the arming off on the first track.
If you are recording into the same track, right click on the record button and select 'Sound on Sound). This will probably do what you want (which is probably not what you really want).
Glen