I was just checking out the demos. When I originally bought X1 I had been looking at Addictive Drums for my drum synth and was particularly interested in the Jazz Brush and Sticks. I ended up getting BFD Eco instead which is a great program as well. Once they added AD to X3 I was very happy because now I had both but wasn't going to drop extra coin on ADPacks.
Anyway... they have really expanded their selection since I was first looking at AD so I'm pretty stoked. At the moment there are unfortunately 4 AdPacks I am really interested in.
Fairfax Vol 1
Metal
Studio Prog
Jazz Brushes
Fairfax Vol 1 is definitely a no brainer for me. I'm a huge Nirvana fan and love the drum sound on Nevermind. I've been trying and dying to emulate that big, smashy sound but it's hard with the kits I currently have. Checking out the demos it definitely sounds to be exactly what I want. The Vol 2 sounds good too but because it's an older kit it's not as tight or loud. Useful for sure but not something I'm prone to gravitate toward. I also have the Rock Legends kit for BFD and SD3 which gets me that kind of early punk sound.
The Metal pack is going to be an either or situation I think. It sounds perfect for metal (and I write a LOT of metal stuff) but I'm not necessarily into that stereotypical "clicky" sound that has wormed it's way on so many albums over the past decade. However this seems to have a good mix of the actual kit sound and the clicky trigger sound AND supposedly you can specifically adjust the blend of that clicky trigger sound and the actual kit. Very cool. Considering metal is something I'll likely be producing a lot of it's probably a good idea to have at least one kit that can acheive the modern metal sound. That stuff can also be really tricky to dial in without the right kit so yeah... I SHOULD get it but I'm almost loathe to succumb to production peer pressure. lol
Studio Prog sounds really good in the mixes they had and I had really wanted to snag one of those Neil Peart kits for SD3 or BFD (I think there is one for BFD through Platinum Samples). This could be a suitable stand in for the Metal pack and kind of solves my problem about having a stereotypical metal drum sound on everything. I do also love me some hyper technical prog stuff which can get all stupid and muddled when trying to program it with a sampler. It says this really let's the hits and artics cut through with a lot of expression so that is very desirable to me. Listening to the presets demo there is also lots of creative sound mangling going on so I like that. Seems rather flexible.
Jazz Brushes is, as I said, something I've wanted for years. I also do folks and country and have a very specific project that requires a nice light brush technique. Thing is though I have a session guy who actually does this stuff as part of the project I need it for anyway. Still it ticks me off because I KNOW I need something like this in my toolbag but at this point I'm not sure how often I'm going to pull it out. The one thing though is I'm not really digging the kit sound for this pack. I mean it sounds good but it is extremely "vintage" sounding... and that's nice but it's to such an extreme that it's almost a parody of a jazz brush sound. It's too specific and old school. Perhaps it is more flexible once installed. It also seems like the type of thing that really needs its companion AdPak, Jazz Sticks. So I'm still deciding and I'll need to see what I already have for the things I'd use it for but sadly I think the other kits, even though they are all somewhat similar, may knock the poor ole Jazz Brush pack out as a contender.
As far as the other possibilities... well between the included content I already have in BFD, SD3 and AD as well as the few banks I've acquired as freebies or on special over the years I think I can easily duplicate that stuff. The Studio Percussion one would be something I could not duplicate easily I guess but I don't see myself accessing that very often and if I need wacky alternate perc sounds there are tons of patches within the various synths that would fill those needs.
I'm actually going to hold of on even updating AD to AD2 for now until I can give Platinum a run through as is (I'm testing a project created in X3 so I want to see if it will be stable as is and THEN update to AD2 to see if that borks anything out). Then I'll do a massive scouring of all my drum sounds to finalize my adpack decision but it will most likely be three of those four paks.
Of course I am always open to opinions and suggestions and will read this thread more thoroughly to see what everyone got and what they think of it all.
Cool thread. Thanks.