I liked the vibe, and your vocals are killer. I'm a fan of your songwriting.
I really didn't vibe with those crushed guitars. Tuning and timing issues don't get lifted up by 4 tons of compression! But if that's what your artistry is telling you, who am I to disagree. ?
Mix-wise, maybe get the bass and all the guitars high pass filtered? What's going on with them below 50hz? You might try cleaning that stuff out, if you haven't already. Maybe 80hz is more like it.
You might also drop the mellotron-pad thing by just a bit.
After listening closely, it might be just the bass guitar that is pulling this into the ditch. What do you think?
Still, dude, you are a great songwriter and singer IMHO and I'm still buying this album.
-Tom