I upgraded to AD2 at XLN when it came out. It was the same thing. There was an offer to upgrade every old content for a specific cost.
But you don't have to do it. You can use the old stuff in AD1 and if you buy any new Adpaks, the AD2 engine is for free.
Same thing now with what you get with Sonar.
Do you get the difference?
I already had AD2 and the upgrade. But the AD2 Producer means, that you get 3 Adpaks and 3 MidiPaks... The engine doesn't cost anything. So I chose some more Paks. Still a great deal.