I paid for a lifetime subscription and in return got months and months of updates and new features for my money.
If Sonar remained as abandonware, I
still would be using it and still getting my initial money's worth.
But now Bandlab is starting from scratch. They have picked up the ball dropped by Gibson and are now running with it. I suspect they will start adding even more updates and features (ones I haven't yet paid for), and I will happily continue to use what I already paid for, and have the
choice to use new features that will be offered.
If you want to get caught up in semantics, then yes, you'll soon be paying for new features that "you should have" been getting for free with your old "Lifetime updates". But through no fault of their own, Bandlab has saved Sonar from oblivion, while at the same time attempting to honor the folks who paid for a lifetime subscription. Meaning that we won't get double charged for features we already paid for! In a perfect world Gibson/Cakewalk would have survived and we'd be getting lifetime updates for free until we croak. But sh*t happens and we're faced with a new reality. I'm satisfied with all the updates and features I already got with my "lifetime" subscription, and I'm greatly relieved that Cakewalk won't stop working now if MS releases a Windows update that might've screwed Sonar up.
I choose to see it as a good thing and I don't feel like I've been screwed or taken advantage of. But obviously others will try and make the WORST out of this situation. And quite honestly, this kind of petty bickering and open hostility makes it seem more like people fighting about politics than a simple change in ownership of DAW software.
Make music and let it go, you'll be much happier and live longer!