I have more than a dozen electric guitar libraries. Why so many? Because the guitar is a versatile and expressive instrument, and sampling one only provides a snapshot of what any particular instrument is capable of. So you end up with a bunch of them, each one specializing in a subset of the guitar universe.
These are the ones I use most...
#1 on my list is
Orange Tree Samples' Strawberry. Not because it's necessarily the best, but rather because it happens to suit what I do the best. If you're into chugging metal rhythm guitar, Electri6ity might be a better choice. The OTS Strat is also very good for expressive leads, but I keep coming back to the Strawberry.
#2 in my toolkit would be Indiginus'
Renegade. Not as versatile as the OTS libraries, but much less expensive and simple to use because it has a great sound right out of the box. Also look at Indiginus' Torch, a similar-sounding instrument.
#3 isn't even an electric guitar, but rather an acoustic. However, I normally run it through an amp sim and use it as if it was an electric guitar. That's Indiginus'
Delta Blues Slide Guitar. Very expressive for leads.
#4 is the
OTS Rickenbacker 12-string. Sounds like the real deal. Great for classic rock, which is my preferred genre, so this one gets used a lot for both rhythm and leads.
Honorable mention: SampleLogic's Cinematic Guitars series. These are more for texture and underscores, but they create sounds I can't easily get with any other guitar library or synthesizer.