Matron Landslide

ampfixer
 
I thought non technical opinion threads were supposed to be in the Coffee House. We have to keep the Sonar page clear for those that actually have questions. ATTN Karyn, John, Beagle.

Agreed (for once ) to be seen fair to others that have had their threads banished, and at the very least for the sake of consistency and to avoid the appearance of hypocrisy, this thread should be moved.

I don't believe that this thread should be anywhere else. It is very topical. Also there is no hypocrisy. It is in keeping with the hello from Meng. However I am sorry that we have descent. 

ampfixer
I thought non technical opinion threads were supposed to be in the Coffee House. We have to keep the Sonar page clear for those that actually have questions. ATTN Karyn, John, Beagle.

Please re-read the OP.  It WAS posted by a forum host. 
 
It is relevant to Sonar, and not just some random off-topic blabbering.  Sonar posts don't need to always be 'technical', just of interest to the Sonar community.  If Noel has made a contribution to the continuing future of Sonar, then we should thank him.

+1000

Bitfipper got there first
http://forum.cakewalk.com/FindPost/3730971
"You got Noel in the deal, that's all I need to hear."
 
All this talk of respect for Noel and you misspell Meng's name.

Matron Landslide
No, it is not consistent with the Hosts own words and actions, it should be moved, it is just gratuitous butt kissing. Whats good for one is good for the other. It's hypocrisy pure and simple.

What a lovely little dark cloud you are! 

ampfixer
I thought non technical opinion threads were supposed to be in the Coffee House. We have to keep the Sonar page clear for those that actually have questions. ATTN Karyn, John, Beagle.

 
I'm happy with this post right where it is. In all the years I've been using this forum I have never been to the Coffee House. I don't think I'm unique in that. If it were posted there, I and many others may have missed the opportunity to recognize and thank Noel for his truly important, bordering on heroic, efforts to save this product. Thank you Noel!

Totally sharp IV. Best to all.

I really fail to understand some peoples attitude and point of view
 
Talk about falling out of the wrong side of the bed - these guys came out of the WOMB the wrong way

Matron Landslide
No, it is not consistent with the Hosts own words and actions, it should be moved, it is just gratuitous butt kissing. Whats good for one is good for the other. It's hypocrisy pure and simple.

Best answer yet. It's great that Noel is still involved and needs to be acknowleged and celebrated but is it really necessary here, as we wait to see what comes of the new company and it's product.

It's premature and off topic as to whether the kudos would be deserved at this point. As far as Noel's past performance that is left to the opinion of those who wish to express it or have expressed in past threads or PM's to him directly or has been suggested in an appropriate subforum.

I'm with ampfixer on this one.

If you wish, you may move this post... a little to the left or right is OK. Or maybe slightly higher, or even a little lower. But not too low... I don't want to accidentally step on it.