I agree, it's not natural sounding at all. I have the RC-20 Retro Color plugin and while I think the vinyl surface noise, tape wobble and tape dropouts can add some nice color and interest to a track, I'm at a loss as to why you'd want to add any of the other varieties of noise they offer.
I mean there's VHS noise, cassette noise, "studio noise" (two kinds), white noise, pink noise, 7.5' tape noise, 15" tape noise, tube noise, DC noise, "Muff" noise (from the Big Muff pedal?), radio noise, 8-bit noise and something called "Apollo." I don't think you'd ever want any of them in a track unless you were genuinely trying to recreate those sounds for a movie or something.
And I hear some people say "oh it adds air"! Really? There are, surely, far better ways of adding air to a track.