Considering there are a few decent interfaces that can be had new for $150 or less, I'd start at that baseline. Because I'm on Firewire, my two backup units are the TC Electronic Konnekt 24D and the Konnekt 6, both of which I picked up cheap on Ebay. I actually use the Konnekt 6 as a general-use sound card for my main PC. Great DA converter/headphone amp, and it cost me all of $50.
For USB2, I'd go with the Steinberg UR12 ($100 new).
If you're okay with B-stock or used, then shop around on Ebay or Reverb.