Open backed, Beyerdynamic DT990Pro are what I'm using at the moment. Pretty flat sound put of the box, just a bit of bass end lift.
Closed back, and so more suitable for tracking to avoid overspill, Senheisser HD25s are reasonably priced and pretty good. Again, something of a bass boost though.
Both are covered by Sonarworks plugin profiles to flatten the response, which is a very useful plugin to have if you have phones that it covers. Waves NX now has a profile for the Beyers.
Though if the same phones that you're very used to are still available new and haven't been significantly changed over the years a straightforward like-for-like replacement might be the best way to go.