2016/02/19 15:00:12
jpetersen
I'll just clump all I put in the announcement thread here, then leave the field open to others for theirs.
Where there are counter arguments, I'll try my best to summarise them (I hope nobody minds..?).
 
1) Also allow the user to decide beforehand where to put them. See the Clone Tracks dialog.
Some possibilities that come to mind:
"Insert Above / Insert Below Current Track"
"Top / Bottom of current folder"
"As First / As Last track in project"
 
2) Option "Midi Only" - add tooltop for new user to clarify this means an external synth.
Paul P said:
You may also just want to create a midi track as part of setting something up.  I think "MIDI Only" should be the default 'Instrument'.  That way it won't be hidden and removes the odd reference to TTS-1.
 
Craig Anderton said:
it could be driving a MIDI-aware signal processor, or someone might want to add several MIDI-only tracks to drive a multi-timbral instrument.
 
3) Head off new user misunderstanding by using either Echo or Monitor (just one name), for the same thing.
Paul P said:
Maybe what the user wants is to monitor the input, but for that to happen the track has to echo its input.
 
4a) Light the Record button in the same red as the other record buttons.
4b) Light the Input Monitor button the same blue as the Input Echo button.
 
I considered breaking them up into one thread per item to make individual voting possible, but I'm not sure the moderators would appreciate that.
2016/02/19 15:26:13
stevec
Voted.   Mainly for consistency in terms for Monitor/Input Echo - I prefer to the Monitor term myself since in DAW terms I don't really want anything to echo.   I've got plenty of Delay FX for that.  
2016/02/19 18:51:03
Zargg
Voted. I think it would add to the usability and consistency for both new and old.
All the best. 
2016/02/20 19:10:58
jpetersen
stevec
Voted.   Mainly for consistency in terms for Monitor/Input Echo - I prefer to the Monitor term myself since in DAW terms I don't really want anything to echo.   I've got plenty of Delay FX for that.  

...and that's not even a joke. I have always kept it off for exactly that reason. It is only after I found a similar button in a competing DAW that I realized it has nothing to do with echo.
© 2024 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account