I'm not really sure what's going on in your rig, but yeah... there should be NO difference between the sound you hear from the project in Sonar and the sound of the mixed stereo wave played by another player through your studio system.
Double check that you don't have something in the mix that's not supposed to be there.... for example, if you use ARC, be sure you shut it off before exporting, double check the routing....
With 30 tracks.... do you have any clones or doubles in the project?
Check this one carefully.......>>>> be sure you don't have doubled, cloned, or bounced tracks in the project that you muted in the project.... BUT.... upon export you selected ALL TRACKS.... as opposed to WHAT YOU HEAR..... that could add all sorts of issues... including phase addition or cancellation of lows, and comb filtering of the highs.... A simple mistake in export option selection could be the issue. I'm not sure that Sonar will do that, but I know there is an entire list of export options and I always choose the What You Hear option for export to avoid grabbing any other tracks by mistake. I've used one of those options to export individual tracks as well a few times and there's a "raw wave" option there too IIRC...