occide
Sorry I disagree with "Uncle Bob"s opinion. If you (or he) think it's true, some data would be nice. What was tested? Which CPUs, which mainboards, which chipsets, what DRAM, which soundcard(s), which software, which plugins... you get the idea. How was it measured? Against what was it compared?
So if anyone has a thing or two to say on the actual topic that would be great. I'm starting to wonder why I still come to this board. Slowly but surely getting hilarious.
FWIW, "Uncle Bob" has been building DAWs professionally for over 20 years.
He's been using DAWs for around 30 years.
I tested **ALL** of the higher end Ryzen motherboards.
Stress-test was DAW Bench (well known low-latency audio specific stress-tests).
Also ran generic Passmark tests...
Ryzen is not particularly great for higher-end gaming... due to the lower clock-speed.
Ryzen is good for heavily multi-threaded applications (video rendering).
For heavily multi-threaded applications at low-latency, you'll want fast RAM.
When running DAW Bench (using their Multi-band compressor for load):
The 6850k bests the 1800x when running the 32Bit version of the multi-band comp.
The 1800x bests the 6850k when running the 645Bit version of the multi-band comp.
You can find my original thread for the test specifics.
In "Uncle Bob's" world, he has to build DAWs for clients (not just himself).
That dramatically changes perspective.
The current state of flaky X370 motherboards would be a nightmare.
As an example, "Uncle Bob" just sent Fred Coury (drummer for Cinderella - now a TV/Film composer) two well endowed DAWs. Fred is the kind of client who can afford
zero downtime.
Do you have any idea the backlash good ol "Uncle Bob" would would receive if Fred's dealing with tight deadlines for The Night Shift... and he suddenly has to pull all system RAM or clear the CMOS to restore SMT?
"Uncle Bob" can't/won't let that happen.
So... thoughtful "Uncle Bob" built Fred's machines using X99 motherboards and 6900k CPUs.
BTW, It's not enough for AMD to simply equal Intel (and especially not at equal price points).
Intel is a well established rock-solid platform.
Clients who can afford zero downtime can't be dealing with flaky components.
They've got work to finish on tight deadlines. Saving $100 is penny wise... dollar foolish.