JonD I'm sure some experiences have been different than mine. Awhile back when Presonus and others were concentrating on firewire, there were a lot of issues mostly related to firewire chip compatibility.
I can only say I have had my Presonus interface for a long time with no issues. The RTL is high compared to some others, true dat. I have been very happy with it concerning stability. Presonus had some driver issues concerning their FW mixers. I'm hoping maybe this most recent interface ups the ante for them.
I did have issues with motu interfaces. Mainly FW comm failure . The Presonus worked fine with the same chipset.
So my OP is mostly my own personal situation and satisfaction with their products. YMMV. For me, form factor is also important. I like the two pres on the front of the Presonus. Others make you either use a patch bay or crawl behind your desk for those quick takes.
Dan I can clearly understand your logic. RME is a no brainer for quality. I would like to see Presonus come out with a winner on this one. I hope they finally deliver something I might seriously look at for vsti work and have lots of i/o.
If I were trying out the Quantum I wouldn't throw away the receipt. Hopefully they have heard the complaints and delivered.