• Songs
  • When I'm Gone (p.2)
2018/03/29 01:30:43
bjornpdx
Rex
Great song! Your voice just comes across so well on this. I listened via headphones.
I liked the 5th line in the verses, the foreboding words with the minor keys in the background.

This is just me probably but that bit about "random gunfire" kind of took me out of it. Seemed like another story line there that needed to be settled. I could accept car crash or something that happens every day and not give it another thought. Just my reaction, like I said.  

Hope you do well with your music.
 
 
2018/03/29 21:20:56
RexRed
When I'm Gone
https://www.reverbnation.com/rexredmusicartist/song/26447051-when-im-gone
 
Okay, this version has an added "solo" component, I also turned up the drums to give them some needed presence.
 
As for the random gun fire line Bjornpdx, I also find that line difficult and an abrupt shift in the song.
 
She could have drown by the river or as you said it could have been in an auto accident. Yet, the reason why I used random gunfire is because of the relevance of that subject in the US where I live.
 
I wanted it to hit home. It is an abrupt line but so is gun fire, abrupt.
 
I could not think of any other way to say it and singing that line was also a task in itself but I delivered it as best I could. I appreciate your opinion and it is something I have debated over also. I could not bring myself to change it. That was the purpose of the song to bring attention to the associated grieving and misfortune of people who are lost due to the abuse and misuse of guns.
 
Please critique the song and these changes. I will try and address your suggestions in future mixes. 
 
Thanks for listening Cakewalk people! :)
 
RR
2018/03/31 00:45:47
Leadfoot
I loved the song Rex. As soon as the vocals started, I immediately flashed back to the early/mid 70's. Sounds like something James Taylor or Bread might have done back in the day. Your voice and the lyrics were great. I feel like the drums and bass need a little more low end, but maybe that's just my preference. Great song!
12
© 2024 APG vNext Commercial Version 5.1

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account