The us1800 is exactly the same as my us1641.
Is this new behavior or has this always behaved this way?
You obviously tried one of the other front XLR inputs, right. I can see one becoming faulty but not all 8 of them.
For me a Sure SM 58 or 57 will be set without clipping when the channel gain is set between 12 to 1 o clock.
I have plugged just about everything into every channel of my unit and it has never been an issue.
Its one of it's strong points is the very flexible input and gain which for me exepts just about any signal from mikes, DI boxes and mixer outputs.
At full anti clockwise there would be almost no signal at all.
To test is this is not something wrong with the peak light system
Arm a track in Sonar and observe the level for the track, is it overdriven?