I believe it is important to maintain constant
rms levels. But of course still use your peak measurement metering at the same time.
If the main concern is to avoid clipping then one great way to do it is to maintain a constant
rms level eg -20 dB FS. Keep all the
rms levels on tracks, buses and the final mix the same eg -20 dB rms = 0 dB VU. If you do this you are directly transferring a metering concept from analog to digital and it still works the same. Peaks take care of themselves and you can get on with other things. The
rms to peak ratio varies all over the place but I say ignore it and let the built in headroom handle it.
If you start seeing clipping lights on then often it is a simple matter to reduce the
rms level slightly. Treat it with a limiter somewhere and bring the transient back under 20 dB. If you do see a clip light even with the
rms metering approach it will usually be so short lived you won’t hear it either.
(Sometimes it can sound good or better) Your peak metering comes in handy and in conjunction with rms metering you have got it all covered. Keeping
rms levels consistent throughout every part of the signal chain makes for very easy production. You have tracked everything perfectly so you always have the right amounts of available level for the mix stages. Your buss mixes are all sitting at the same
rms level as well as your final mix. Every mix will be the same volume too before any mastering begins.
rms levels tie in perfectly with loudness measurements and dynamic range measurements. Peak levels are related to the
rms parts they are attached to. They are important. They add the snap to the sound and give us the all important dynamics. Peak metering is fast and it lets us see how high those transient peaks really are.
Pick an
rms level and put everything you do
rms wise right there at that level. Link you room SPL level to that level as well. Drop everything you do down and you will naturally move away from 0 dB FS. Turn the level of your monitoring up and hear how perfect everything can sound. All because you are keeping an eye now on both components of the signal.
rms and peak. And now keeping the
rms component at a ref level like we used to. I see it as the
rms component representing the body of the signal. The peak reading the transient component of the signal.
Nothing has changed much even in our digital recording world. All the source signals are the same, mics on drums, guitars, vocals percussion you name it. Synths (hardware) are all analog outputs mostly. There is so much analog that still exists well prior to the digital recording medium. So it pays to keep an analog metering concept alive to meter that and why not continue to meter that way right through the digital medium and out the other end. It works for me and sounds great. Digital sounds great when you operate it this way too.