Kev999
I wouldn't leave the entire recording on a single track hoping for a one-size-fits-all solution. I would split off the problematic sections (e.g. noisy kids interruptions) onto a separate track and treat them separately.
Interesting thought, but curious - while I have no problem chopping up a guitar part so that it only plays when the guitar is playing, that is in the context of a mix. If I was recording say an acoustic guitar, I would expect string noise, other hand noise... to be part of the recording. As such, how do you do this with spoken dialog?
If spoken dialog is coming from -100 db to 0 db (or whatever) by chopping out the unimportant parts (kids...), wouldn't that come across somewhat unnatural? Would you recommend a low level tape hiss or the likes to provide a more realistic reproduction?
I still think a leveling compressor is needed to tame the extreme peaks.