brundlefly
John
I insert a MIDI track in it and whether echo is on or not when I press a key on the MIDI keyboard and the MIDI meter lights up.
...
...
The MIDI meters show activity on the track. Echo has nothing to do with it. It shouldn't matter what the condition of echo is for MIDI whether its coming from a keyboard or has been previously recorded.
Unless there's a config setting I don't know about, I think you're mistaken about this, John. MIDI track meters are output meters only. They only show activity if existing MIDI is playing back or live input is being echoed. Even arming the track does not switch the meters to the input side as you might expect.
Try it. In the case I outlined above the transport was not moving there was sound from the synth and nothing was being recorded. However it was using a hardware synth a Sound Canvas which is the default for a new MIDI track as output on my system. Basically its just being used as a transfer point for MIDI. As if it were MIDI through. If however I set that track to record it would. Before I posted I did exactly what I described on my system. Sonar has always worked this way.
BTW I use the right click menu to insert a track.
Update:
OK I just tried it with a project for audio. This project is two audio tracks meant for playback only. Each one is a song. The MIDI track I inserted did not show any MIDI activity but the synth did sound. This is not as it should be.
I will have to look into this further. Echo had no effect on or off. On inserting a MIDI track into my empty project it did as it had before. MIDI activity was showing.
I created a new project from a CW template one audio and one MIDI track and the results were the same for the empty project. Activity was seen and sound was heard. Now I am baffled.
One cool thing Brundelfly is I know you know what you are talking about. I trust you completely. I'm just not seeing the same as you.
I retested the 2 song project and it agrees with what you are saying. The other projects don't. More baffled.